LIVE
OCD← Home
War and Peace cover
1869
War and Peace
Leo Tolstoy · Bureaucratic Power Games
Chapter 110
Ch. 109
Reading
Ch. 110
Ch. 111
Loading audio...
0:000:00

Prince Andrew arrives in Petersburg in August 1809, when youthful Speránski is at the zenith of his fame and reforms are being pushed with the greatest energy. That same August the Emperor is thrown from his calèche, injures his leg, and remains three weeks at Peterhof, receiving Speránski every day and no one else. Two famous decrees that so agitate society are being prepared: abolishing court ranks and introducing examinations to qualify for Collegiate Assessor and State Councilor, and not merely these but a whole state constitution intended to change legal, administrative, and financial government from the Council of State down to district tribunals. The vague liberal dreams with which Alexander ascended the throne, tried with Czartorýski, Novosíltsev, Kochubéy, and Strógonov, whom he jested as his Comité de salut public, are taking shape. Now those men are replaced by Speránski on the civil side and Arakchéev on the military.

Soon after arrival Andrew, as a gentleman of the chamber, presents himself at court and at a levee. The Emperor meets him twice and does not favour him with a single word. It has always seemed to Andrew that he was antipathetic to the Emperor, that the latter disliked his face and personality; the cold, repellent glance now confirms the surmise. Courtiers explain the neglect by His Majesty's displeasure at Bolkónski's not having served since 1805. One cannot help one's sympathies and antipathies, Andrew thinks, so it will not do to present the army-regulation project to the Emperor personally; the project will speak for itself. He mentions what he has written to an old field marshal, a friend of his father's, who receives him graciously and promises to inform the Emperor. A few days later Andrew is told to see the Minister of War, Count Arakchéev.

On the appointed day he enters Arakchéev's waiting room at nine in the morning. He does not know the minister personally and has heard little to inspire respect, but the man is trusted by the Emperor and commissioned to consider the project. The anteroom has a special character: unimportant faces show embarrassment and servility; higher rank covers awkwardness with unconcern and self-ridicule. Some walk up and down; others whisper. Andrew hears the nickname Síla Andréevich and Uncle will give it to us hot. A general sits crossing and uncrossing his legs, smiling contemptuously at having to wait. The moment the door opens, one feeling alone appears on all faces: fear. Andrew asks the adjutant a second time to take in his name and receives an ironical look: his turn will come. An officer with a humiliated, frightened air is admitted; the audience lasts a long time; a harsh grating voice is heard; the officer comes out pale, lips trembling, clutching his head. Andrew is conducted in: to the right, at the window. A man of forty, long waist, closely cropped head, deep wrinkles, scowling brows, dull greenish-hazel eyes, overhanging red nose, turns his head without looking. What is your petition? Andrew quietly says he is not petitioning; the Emperor has deigned to send a project. Arakchéev reads that there are many laws but no one to carry out the old ones; nowadays everybody designs laws; writing is easier than doing. Across the paper is scrawled in pencil, without capitals, misspelled, without punctuation: unsoundly constructed because it resembles an imitation of the French military code and needlessly deviates from the Articles of War. The memorandum has gone to the Committee on Army Regulations; Andrew is recommended as a member, but without a salary. Andrew smiles that he does not want one. A member without salary, Arakchéev repeats, bows, and shouts for the next.

Amplified Discussion
Why Good Ideas Die in Bad Systems

Tolstoy shows us something uncomfortable: sometimes the people blocking progress aren't evil, they're just protecting what little power they have. Count Arakchéev isn't a cartoon villain; he's a man whose entire identity depends on being the gatekeeper of military reform. If Prince Andrew's ideas succeed, what happens to Arakchéev's importance? This dynamic plays out everywhere: the supervisor who shoots down employee suggestions because they didn't think of them first, the committee chair who tables every proposal to maintain control, the department head who hoards information to stay relevant. These people aren't necessarily trying to hurt others, they're trying to survive in systems that taught them their worth comes from being indispensable rather than being helpful. The tragedy is that their self-preservation often prevents the very improvements that could help everyone, including themselves. Understanding this pattern doesn't excuse the behavior, but it explains why good intentions and solid logic often aren't enough to create change. Sometimes the system itself needs to shift before the people within it can act differently. The question becomes: when you encounter institutional resistance, are you dealing with legitimate concerns about your idea, or are you threatening someone's sense of security and identity?

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Reading Institutional Gatekeeping

Good work can die in a frightened waiting room. Andrew's regulations reach Arakchéev, who rules by terror and rejects the memo as French imitation. When a room runs on fear, test whether rejection is about your idea or about who loses if it succeeds.

Lessons

PracticeList three allies outside the hostile office before you resubmit a blocked proposal.

Psych reading

Bureaucratic Gatekeeping

People in power dismiss competent proposals to protect turf, using fear, prejudice, and procedure as weapons.

In the mind

Andrew's careful army project meets Arakchéev's fear-filled room and a scribbled refusal.

The mechanism is institutional immunity: position beats merit, terror beats debate.

You see it when a clerk's note ends a months-long proposal without reading.

Document the work, find alternate sponsors, and do not confuse access with justice.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors