Smith grounds virtue in two reciprocal efforts already described: the spectator's attempt to enter another's sentiments, and the agent's attempt to moderate passion to a pitch others can share. From the first come the amiable virtues of tenderness, indulgence, and humanity; from the second the respectable virtues of self-command, dignity, and governed anger. Soft sympathy that re-echoes friends' fortunes is lovable, while clamorous grief or unchecked rage disgusts us, and restrained sorrow or measured resentment commands reverence. To love our neighbour as ourselves, he notes, pairs with loving ourselves only as our neighbour can love us.
True virtue, however, is not ordinary propriety but uncommon excellence. Humanity demands more sensibility than the vulgar possess; magnanimity demands more self-command than most can exert. Eating when hungry is proper but not virtuous, while falling short of perfect propriety in extreme trials may still deserve praise because the effort approaches perfection more closely than circumstances allow.
We therefore judge actions by two standards: an ideal of complete propriety no conduct reaches, and the common level actually attained in human life. The same double measure applies in art criticism when we compare a work with perfection and with its rivals. Smith closes by noting that decency in expressing passion depends on how far mankind generally sympathize with that passion, which sets different proper pitches for grief, resentment, love, and bodily appetite.
Smith identified something we still struggle with today: we have two completely different ideas of what makes someone admirable, and we often judge people unfairly when they excel at one but not the other. Think about workplace dynamics. The manager who remembers everyone's birthdays and checks in during tough times gets labeled as caring but maybe weak. The manager who stays level-headed during layoffs and makes hard decisions fairly gets called strong but possibly heartless. We want both qualities in the same person, but Smith shows us that's unrealistic and unfair. The empathetic person might crumble under pressure because feeling others' pain deeply makes it harder to make tough choices. The self-controlled person might seem distant because managing emotions requires putting up barriers. Neither is failing - they're succeeding at different types of virtue. This plays out in families too. Some relatives are the ones you call when you need emotional support, others are who you turn to in a crisis. Some friends feel your joy and pain with you, others help you think clearly when emotions run high. The problem comes when we expect the empathetic person to also be the rock, or demand that the steady person also be the emotional connector. Smith suggests we should appreciate both paths and stop penalizing people for not being everything to everyone.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion