Smith defines moral propriety through concord between a person's original passion and the spectator's sympathetic response. When resentment, grief, admiration, or laughter in another matches what we would feel on bringing the case home to ourselves, we approve it as just and suitable; disproportionate feeling appears improper. Approving opinions and approving passions are the same operation: we adopt what coincides with our own sentiments and reject what does not. His standard is blunt: every faculty in one person measures the like faculty in another.
Experience also supplies conditional sympathy when present mood blocks full feeling. We may approve a jest we do not laugh at because we know we would on most occasions, or a stranger's grief at a father's death while occupied elsewhere, because we know that with time and attention we would share it. General rules drawn from past cases correct our immediate emotions when they would otherwise misfire.
Smith then separates how we judge a passion from its cause and from its effects. Excessive love, grief, or resentment is blamed both for harmful outcomes and for weak occasion: the favourite is not worth it, the misfortune not so dreadful, the provocation not so extraordinary. Propriety in the first sense is measured only by the correspondent affection in ourselves, and we have no other route to judging what fits.
Every day, we unconsciously judge whether other people's emotions are 'appropriate' by measuring them against our own internal scale. When a coworker gets upset about criticism, when a family member overreacts to a slight, when someone seems too calm about what feels like a crisis to us—we're constantly scoring their emotional responses. Smith identified this as a fundamental feature of human judgment, not a bug. We literally cannot help using ourselves as the measuring stick because our own experiences are the only reference point we have access to. But here's the problem: we forget that everyone's emotional thermostat was calibrated by different experiences. The single mother working two jobs might have a hair-trigger response to disrespect because she faces it constantly. The military veteran might seem emotionally flat about relationship drama because he's seen actual life-and-death situations. The teenager might be devastated by social rejection because her brain is literally wired to prioritize peer acceptance for survival. When we dismiss these responses as 'overreactions' or 'underreactions,' we're imposing our emotional scale on their reality. Smith suggests that true moral judgment requires us to step outside our own experience and imagine what we would feel if we had lived their life, faced their challenges, carried their burdens. This doesn't mean accepting all behavior, but it means understanding the feelings behind it before we judge.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion