Smith asks why fortune distorts moral judgment by tracing gratitude and resentment to their roots. Pain and pleasure excite these passions even toward inanimate things. We curse the stone that hurts us. A child beats it, a dog barks at it, a choleric man is apt to curse it. We burn the instrument that killed a friend, and cherish the plank that saved a sailor from shipwreck. Dryads and Lares, he suggests, arose from this affection for houses and trees. Reflection soon corrects revenge against what cannot feel.
Yet complete satisfaction requires an object that causes pleasure or pain, can feel, and acted from a design we approve or condemn. Animals approach this standard more nearly than objects, but still fall short. We are shocked at the officer in the Turkish Spy who stabbed the horse that had carried him across an arm of the sea, lest the animal distinguish someone else by a similar adventure. Gratitude wants the benefactor to know he is rewarded for past conduct; resentment wants the offender to know he is punished for contempt shown to us. When an enemy injured us justly, resentment cannot stand.
Failed beneficence and failed malice therefore receive diminished passion because an exciting cause is absent. Lucky harm or benefit casts a shadow of demerit or merit on agents whose hearts were not properly tuned. Hence fortune governs our sense of desert.
Smith identified something we see everywhere today: our tendency to shoot the messenger instead of addressing the message. The nurse gets yelled at for the diagnosis. The cashier gets attitude about corporate policies. The customer service rep bears the brunt of system failures they didn't create. This happens because our emotional wiring evolved to respond to intentional agents - people who could actually mean us harm or good. But modern life constantly puts us in contact with representatives of systems, not the decision-makers themselves. We know intellectually that the person in front of us didn't create the problem, but our emotional system fires anyway. Smith's insight reveals why this feels so unsatisfying - true emotional resolution requires three things: the target must have caused the outcome, be capable of feeling, and have acted intentionally. When we yell at someone who's just doing their job, we're missing at least one of these elements. The person might feel our anger, but they didn't cause our problem and weren't acting with intent to harm us. Understanding this pattern helps us redirect our energy more effectively. Instead of making some working person's day miserable, we can channel that frustration toward the actual decision-makers or systematic changes that might prevent future problems. The question becomes: are we seeking genuine resolution or just looking for someone to absorb our anger?
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion