Smith analyses merit and demerit as compound sentiments built on sympathy. Sense of propriety arises from direct sympathy with the agent's motives; sense of merit adds indirect sympathy with beneficiaries' gratitude. Reading of Scipio or Camillus transports us into noble designs, then into the warm thanks of those they saved, so that recompense seems fit and shocking when undervalued.
Demerit pairs direct antipathy to vicious motives with indirect sympathy for victims' resentment. Contemplating Borgia or Nero repels us from their sentiments while inflaming indignation for the oppressed; imagined punishment satisfies our sense of ill desert. Smith defends tracing demerit partly through resentment. Properly moderated resentment wins esteem when it matches spectators' indignation, whereas excess becomes odious revenge. Too violent resentment, instead of carrying us along with it, becomes itself the object of our indignation. We enter the opposite resentment of the person in danger from that unjust emotion. Revenge, the excess of resentment, appears the most detestable of the passions, and in ordinary life it is excessive a hundred times for once that it is moderate.
He insists this is descriptive psychology, not ideal legislation. Society needs instinctive approval of punishing unprovoked malice, as nature couples appetites for ends with appetites for means. The inquiry is not how a perfect being would approve punishment, but how so weak a creature as man actually does. Finally, merit approval differs from propriety approval because grateful sympathy in the spectator can suffice even without matching feelings in the recipient.
Smith makes an uncomfortable argument: anger isn't just acceptable in moral judgment - it's essential. Without the ability to feel angry on behalf of victims, we'd have no motivation to punish wrongdoers or protect the innocent. This challenges modern ideas about staying calm and rational in conflicts. Smith shows that the problem isn't anger itself, but anger that's either too weak (letting injustice slide) or too strong (becoming vindictive). The sweet spot is proportional anger - feeling exactly what any reasonable person would feel in that situation. This applies everywhere from workplace harassment to family dynamics. When your coworker gets sexually harassed, your anger on her behalf isn't unprofessional - it's moral. When a manager steals credit from your team, your resentment isn't petty - it's justice-seeking. The key is calibrating that anger to match the situation. Too little, and wrongdoers face no consequences. Too much, and you become the problem. Smith reveals that our 'negative' emotions often serve positive social functions. The question isn't whether to feel angry about injustice, but how to channel that anger constructively.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion