Smith identifies a third family of passions between the social and unsocial: grief and joy about our own private fortune. They are never as odious as resentment nor as attractive as impartial benevolence, and they lack the double or opposed sympathy those sets provoke. Yet joy and grief diverge in what others will share: we sympathize more readily with small joys than great ones, and with great sorrows than small ones.
Sudden elevation in rank illustrates the asymmetry. Friends' congratulations to an upstart are tinged with envy; if he is wise he suppresses elation, dresses plainly, and courts old companions, yet sincerity is suspected and constraint usually fails, leaving isolation from peers above and below. Gradual advancement is happier because public expectation absorbs each step. By contrast, habitual cheerfulness over everyday pleasures, youth, and small domestic satisfactions wins easy sympathy when envy does not interfere.
Grief follows the opposite scale. Petty vexations from cooks, weather, or missed greetings earn ridicule and raillery because listeners resist trifling sorrow and often enjoy teasing it; well-bred people disguise or joke about such pains. Deep poverty, disease, or disgrace, even partly self-caused, calls forth sincere compassion and aid. Smith's implication is sharp: calibrate your expectations of sympathy to the real weight of your fortune, not to how loudly you feel it.
Smith identified something brutal about human nature: we're hardwired to resent dramatic success in others, even people we love. This isn't a character flaw - it's evolutionary psychology. For thousands of years, resources were scarce. Someone else's big win often meant less for everyone else. That mental programming persists even when success isn't zero-sum. Today, we see this everywhere. The coworker who gets promoted suddenly faces cold shoulders from former peers. The friend who loses weight gets subtle digs about 'showing off.' The neighbor who buys a nicer car triggers whispered complaints about 'getting above themselves.' Social media amplifies this by putting everyone's highlights on display, creating constant opportunities for comparison and resentment. But here's what Smith understood that we often miss: the successful person usually pays a higher price than we realize. They gain status but lose the very relationships that made life meaningful. The promotion comes with isolation. The weight loss comes with friends who no longer invite them out. The new house comes with family members asking for money. Understanding this pattern doesn't make the envy disappear, but it helps us recognize it as automatic rather than justified. When we can name what's happening, we can choose a different response.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion