Rising by luck or another person's power is easy. Keeping the summit is not. Machiavelli compares princes lifted by fortune or a patron's favor to things that grow too fast: unless a man of great ability builds foundations after the elevation, the first storm knocks him over.
Francesco Sforza and Cesare Borgia show the contrast. Sforza climbed through ability and kept Milan with little trouble afterward. Borgia, Duke Valentino, built during his father Pope Alexander VI's rise and lost everything when that rise reversed, even though he did nearly everything a wise prince should do to secure territory others had given him. Machiavelli knew Borgia personally and treats him as the best lesson for anyone raised by fortune or foreign arms.
Alexander embroiled Italy to carve out Romagna for his son, using French arms at first. Once Borgia saw Orsini troops waver and France stop his Tuscan advance, he decided never again to depend on others' luck. He broke the Roman factions, lured the Orsini to Sinigalia and destroyed them, then won the Romagna by first giving Ramiro d'Orco brutal authority to restore order and later executing Ramiro in public so the people blamed the minister, not the duke. Before Alexander's death Borgia had cleared dispossessed lords, won Roman gentlemen, stacked the college, and was expanding toward Tuscany until he stood almost on his own power.
Then fortune turned vicious. Alexander died. Borgia was sick, caught between French and Spanish armies, with much of his gains still in the air. His foundations still held: Romagna waited for him, Rome stayed secure even while enemies prowled the city. Machiavelli argues Borgia should be imitated, not blamed, except for one fatal error: allowing Julius II, a cardinal he had injured, to become pope. New benefits do not erase old injuries from great men. That mistake, not lack of talent, finished him.
Machiavelli's longest case study asks a practical question: what do you do when power lands in your lap through someone else?
The opening is blunt. Fortune-made princes fly upward and crash at the summit because they lack command experience and loyal forces of their own. Borgia is the counterexample who tried to fix that after the fact. Using his father's papacy and French arms, he took the Romagna, then saw the danger of borrowed force when Orsini soldiers hesitated and King Louis blocked his Tuscan move. From that point he built his own base: break Roman factions, destroy the Orsini at Sinigalia, pacify the Romagna through Ramiro d'Orco and then sacrifice Ramiro to the crowd, and prepare for Alexander's death by killing dispossessed lords, winning Roman gentlemen, and packing the college.
Machiavelli admired the method enough to say Borgia should be imitated by anyone raised through fortune or others' arms. Fortune still broke him when Alexander died early, Borgia fell ill, and great powers closed in. Even then his foundations held briefly in Romagna and Rome. The one clear mistake was political, not tactical: letting Julius II, a cardinal Borgia had injured, become pope. Borrowed power can be converted, but not if you leave an old enemy on the throne above you.
In modern terms: Power gained through fortune or a patron must be converted quickly into loyal forces of your own before the elevation reverses
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion