Machiavelli gathers the remaining qualities under one rule: avoid what makes a prince hated or despised. Hatred comes above all from rapacity and from violating subjects' property and women; when those are untouched most men live content and only a few ambitious men need curbing. Contempt comes from seeming fickle, frivolous, effeminate, mean spirited, or irresolute, so a prince should show greatness, courage, gravity, and fortitude, with judgments so firm that no one hopes to deceive him.
Internal conspiracy is the chief domestic danger when outside affairs are quiet. The best remedy is not to be hated or despised by the people, because conspirators expect to please the public by removing a prince; if they would only offend the people, they rarely dare act. Machiavelli cites Annibale Bentivogli of Bologna: after his murder the people destroyed the conspirators and later restored the Bentivogli even through a blacksmith's son until Giovanni came of age. Well ordered France shows another device: parliament absorbs reproach while the king keeps grace, and nobles are cherished without making the prince hated by the people.
Roman emperors after Marcus Aurelius complicate the rule because they faced a third force: greedy, cruel soldiers who wanted a warlike rapacious prince while the people wanted peace. When a prince cannot escape all hatred, he must avoid the hatred of the most powerful group. Marcus alone ended well among the mild emperors because he inherited power and kept both soldiers and people in place. Pertinax and the humane Alexander were destroyed; Pertinax because reforming soldiers bred hatred and age bred contempt, Alexander because effeminacy made him despised.
Severus succeeded by satisfying soldiers while oppressing the people, using fox and lion against Niger and Albinus until renown shielded him from popular hatred. Caracalla, Commodus, and Maximinus show the limits: excessive cruelty, contemptible behavior, or low birth can still destroy a prince. Modern rulers usually must satisfy the people rather than soldiers, except the Turk and the Soldan. A new prince should take from Severus what is needed to found a state and from Marcus what is proper to keep one already stable.
Chapter 19 is Machiavelli's longest conduct chapter and his most practical guide to survival. He opens with the two fatal stains: hatred from rapacity and violations of property and women, contempt from weakness, frivolity, and irresolution. A prince who looks grave, courageous, and impossible to fool is hard to conspire against.
The middle shifts from personal bearing to political structure. Popular goodwill defeats conspiracy because assassins expect applause, not outrage. Bentivogli's Bologna proves the point, and France shows how to offload reproach while keeping grace. Then Machiavelli tackles the Roman emperor objection. Emperors faced soldiers as a third faction with appetites opposite the people's. Marcus survived by inheritance and balance; Pertinax and Alexander fell to hatred and contempt; Severus succeeded through fox, lion, and renown that kept hatred from turning fatal.
The closing updates the rule for modern princes: today the people usually matter more than soldiers, except in Turk and Soldan states. The final instruction is strategic synthesis. New princes cannot imitate Marcus wholesale or Severus completely, but should take from Severus what founds a state and from Marcus what keeps one firm.
In modern terms: A prince survives by leaving property and honour untouched, appearing strong and decisive, keeping popular goodwill against conspiracies, and choosing the right imperial example for founding versus preserving
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion