Machiavelli turns from arms to conduct, warning that he will depart from other writers because he follows the real truth of the matter, not imaginary republics that were never seen. How one lives is so far from how one ought to live that he who neglects what is done for what ought to be done destroys himself sooner than he preserves himself. A man who tries to live entirely by professions of virtue is ruined among so much evil.
A prince who wishes to hold his own must therefore know how to do wrong, and use that knowledge or not according to necessity. Machiavelli sets aside imaginary princes and lists the qualities for which men, especially princes, are praised or blamed: liberal or miserly, generous or rapacious, cruel or compassionate, faithful or faithless, bold or cowardly, affable or haughty, sincere or cunning, religious or unbelieving, and the rest.
Everyone admits it would be best to show all the good qualities, but human conditions do not permit it. The prince must be prudent enough to avoid the reproach of vices that would lose him his state, keep away when possible from vices that would not, and when he cannot, accept the lesser vices with less hesitation. He need not worry about blame for vices without which the state can barely be saved, because what looks like virtue may ruin him while what looks like vice may bring security and prosperity.
Chapter 15 opens the famous second half of The Prince by breaking with moral instruction as usual writers give it. Machiavelli says he will be called presumptuous, but usefulness requires truth rather than imagined republics. The gap between how one lives and how one ought to live is the chapter's foundation: idealism that ignores reality destroys the prince faster than it saves him.
The middle names the moral vocabulary people use to judge rulers, pairing virtues and vices across liberality, cruelty, faith, courage, manners, religion, and cunning. Everyone will say a prince should show all the good qualities. Human conditions forbid it. Prudence therefore means sorting which vices actually cost you the state from which ones are merely ugly but survivable.
Machiavelli's conclusion is the line that shocked readers ever after: necessary wrongdoing is part of rule, and reputational blame may be the price of keeping the state alive. What looks virtuous can ruin you; what looks vicious can secure you. The next chapters will walk through the virtues one by one. This one establishes the rule that appearances and survival will not always align.
In modern terms: A prince must know how to do wrong when necessity demands it, avoid only the vices that cost the state, and accept that virtue in appearance can ruin while vice in appearance can save
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion