Ernest is at the house so often that Avis stops pretending the dinners are the only draw. His gaze and his handshake grow firmer, and the question in his eyes does not go away. She has already moved through dislike, attraction, and repulsion. When he is asked to speak at the Philomath Club, the monthly room of men who own the city, he begins with the childhood that starved flesh and spirit alike. Upstairs, he had believed, lived unselfishness of the spirit and clean thinking. He had learned that paradise from cheap novels in which, villains aside, the rich thought beautiful thoughts, spoke a beautiful tongue, and performed glorious deeds.
He tells them what he found when he finally entered that paradise: not clean thinking, but money-talk under religious speech, and faces that change when lordship is named. Avis hears what he hears, a growl the pack does not know it is making. Harshness forms in their faces. Fight-light flashes in their eyes. She understands, before he finishes the charge, that they will not let the world be wrested from them easily. He accounts for a million and a half revolutionists by mismanagement. Productive power has increased a thousand-fold, and children still work in factories while millions stay poor. He asks them to answer the charge. They grow louder instead of answering.
Colonel Van Gilbert, the corporate lawyer, tries to swat him with youth and fallacy. Ernest puts the lawyer back in his trade. On the law of thieving corporations, Ernest says, he is in the dirt at Van Gilbert's feet. On sociology, Van Gilbert is in the dirt at his. Law is the stuff of a day; rash generalisations about history are not worth the breath spent on them. The room likes the hit until it understands the hit is on them. Mr Wickson, the coolest head present, finally drops the debate. He does not try to win on history or economics. He says the class in that room will not be argued out of lordship. They will keep the world by force if argument fails them, and they will do it without the embarrassment of a moral defence.
Ernest answers with the word the labour hosts have been learning until their minds tingle with it: power. He has already told Van Gilbert to stay in his trade. Now he tells the whole club the same thing in one syllable. It does not matter whether the dragging-down takes a year, ten, or a thousand. Both sides have now said out loud that votes will not decide who rules. And so the night ends on that kingly word, with the Philomath Club still seated and the coming fight already named.
London exposes a psychological mechanism that transcends his era: when people benefit from a broken system, they develop elaborate mental frameworks to avoid confronting their role in perpetuating harm. Ernest's wealthy audience can't engage with his economic arguments because doing so would require admitting their comfortable lives depend on others' suffering. This same pattern plays out everywhere today. Hospital administrators justify dangerous understaffing by citing 'efficiency metrics' while nurses work themselves into burnout.
Corporate managers blame 'market forces' for layoffs while taking bonuses. Family members dismiss concerns about addiction or abuse by attacking the messenger's credibility rather than addressing the behavior. The pattern is predictable: first denial of the problem, then intellectual dismissal of the messenger, finally naked assertion of power to shut down the conversation. What makes this particularly insidious is that those employing these tactics often genuinely believe they're being reasonable.
They've constructed entire worldviews that cast their harmful choices as necessary, even noble. London shows us that expecting logical debate with people whose comfort depends on not understanding your point is a strategic error. The real question becomes: once you can see this pattern clearly, how do you navigate around it rather than exhausting yourself trying to break through it?
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion