The days are short in November, and it is quite late when Alyosha rings at the prison gate. Dusk is beginning. He knows he will be admitted without difficulty. Grushenka, Alyosha, and Rakitin are allowed to see the prisoner alone. Rakitin leaves. Mitya takes it as a whole, and he is sorry to lose God. Imagine, he says: inside, in the nerves, in the head, a second passes, and then something like a moment appears. Not a moment. An image. An object, or an action. Who was Claude Bernard? A chemist, or what? Rakitin, he says, will write that he could not help murdering his father, that he was corrupted by his environment, and that he will put in a tinge of Socialism.
Rakitin writes verses, too, on Madame Hohlakov's foot. Mitya has the poem. He has got it, and he will read it. Then the dream of the babe comes back. Why is the babe so poor? That was a sign. It is for the babe he is going, because they are all responsible for all. If they drive God from the earth, we shall shelter Him underground. What should I be underground there without God? There will be hundreds of them, with hammers in their hands. They will be in chains and there will be no freedom, but then, in their great sorrow, there is the hymn. One cannot exist in prison without God. Rakitin is laughing. Ah, man should be dissolved in prayer.
He has taken all Grushenka's soul into his soul, and through her he has become a man himself. Will they marry us? If they do not, he will die of jealousy. They do not let convicts marry, do they? He says it again, holding Alyosha with both hands on his shoulders, his yearning, feverish eyes fixed on his brother. He cannot live without Grusha. Wait till after the trial. Alyosha listens with extreme surprise, and is deeply moved.
Ivan suggests his escaping. Ivan understands about the hymn, only he does not speak. He does not believe in the hymn. Do not decide. Spare me. Sign me with the cross, darling, for the cross I have to bear tomorrow. They embrace and kiss. Then Mitya asks for the truth, as Alyosha would speak it before God. Do you believe I did it? Do you, do you in yourself, believe it? The whole truth, do not lie. Everything seems heaving before Alyosha. I have never for one instant believed that you were the murderer. He raises his right hand, as though calling God to witness. Mitya's whole face is lighted up with bliss. Thank you, he says slowly, as though a sigh escaped him after fainting.
Dostoevsky wrote The Brothers Karamazov during a period of intense personal suffering—the death of his young son, gambling addiction, crushing debt. Yet this pain produced his greatest masterpiece. Mitya's discovery that he could 'sing hymns underground' reflects Dostoevsky's own realization that meaning doesn't come from avoiding hardship but from transforming it. This pattern challenges our modern assumption that suffering is always meaningless, something to medicate or escape. In Dostoevsky's Russia, the concept of 'redemptive suffering'—that pain could purify and transform—was deeply embedded in Orthodox Christianity. Today's working-class Americans might find this idea foreign, raised in a culture that promises happiness and comfort as birthrights. Yet many discover what Mitya learned: their most difficult experiences—addiction recovery, caring for aging parents, surviving layoffs—become the source of their greatest strength and deepest wisdom. The chapter doesn't romanticize suffering or suggest we should seek it out. Instead, it reveals how to recognize when hardship is trying to teach us something essential about who we could become. Mitya's willingness to accept responsibility, even for suffering he didn't directly cause, points to a radical idea: that our growth often requires us to carry more than our fair share, not because we're victims, but because we're strong enough to transform pain into purpose.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion