The head of the Chi family stages eight rows of pantomimes, a display reserved for a king. If he can bear to do this, the Master asks, what may he not bear to do? The three families then sing the YUNG ode in their own hall, words meant for princes assisting the son of heaven. Without the virtues proper to humanity, he says, what has a man to do with rites or music? Lin Fang asks what comes first in ceremonies. Festive rites should be sparing, not extravagant. Mourning should have deep sorrow, not a minute attention to observances. The Chi chief then reaches for a sacrifice on the T'ai mountain. Zan Yu cannot stop him. The Master asks whether the mountain is less discerning than Lin Fang. Tsze-hsia hears that colour is laid on after the ground is prepared. Ceremonies, then, come after the ground.
He could describe the rites of Hsia and Yin, but Chi and Sung cannot attest his words. After the libation at the great sacrifice he has no wish to look on. Asked its meaning, he says he does not know. The person who did would find governing the kingdom as easy as looking at his palm. He sacrifices to the dead and to the spirits as if they were present. Not to be present is not to sacrifice. Wang-sun Chia quotes a saying that it is better to pay court to the furnace than to the south-west corner. The Master refuses. He who offends against Heaven has none to whom he can pray. He follows Chau. In the grand temple he asks about everything. When someone mocks him as the son of the man of Tsau who does not know propriety, he answers that this is a rule of propriety.
Tsze-kung wants to drop the monthly sheep. The Master loves the ceremony, not the sheep. Full observance of propriety towards a prince is counted as flattery. Duke Ting is told to employ ministers by the rules of propriety, and ministers to serve with faithfulness. Kwan Chung keeps a screen and a cup-stand that belong to princes. If that is propriety, who does not know it? A border warden at Yi tells the disciples not to mourn the Master's loss of office. Heaven will use him as a bell with a wooden tongue in a kingdom long without truth and right. The Shao is perfectly beautiful and perfectly good. The Wu is perfectly beautiful but not perfectly good. High station filled without generosity, ceremonies without reverence, mourning without sorrow: wherewith should I contemplate such ways?
Confucius lived in an era when social order was crumbling and people were grabbing for status they hadn't earned. Sound familiar? Today's workplace is flooded with borrowed authority—managers who mistake process for progress, leaders who confuse busy work with productivity, supervisors who think commanding respect is the same as earning it. The Chi family's stolen ceremonies mirror the modern phenomenon of management theater: endless meetings that accomplish nothing, elaborate reporting systems that obscure rather than clarify, and the elevation of credentials over competence. But here's what Confucius understood that we often forget: authentic authority doesn't need to announce itself. Real leaders ask questions, admit what they don't know, and focus on serving their team rather than being served by it. When someone has genuine expertise, they welcome scrutiny because they have real knowledge to share. When someone is performing authority, they deflect questions and hide behind procedure. The pattern reveals itself in how people respond to challenge. Borrowed authority crumbles under genuine inquiry, while authentic leadership grows stronger through honest examination. The question isn't whether you have a title or degree—it's whether you can deliver results and build trust through consistent competence and care for others.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion