LIVE
OCD← Home
The Essays of Montaigne cover
1580
The Essays of Montaigne
Michel de Montaigne · Three Greatest Men in History
Chapter 92
Ch. 91
Reading
Ch. 92
Ch. 93
Loading audio...
0:000:00

Asked whom he ranks highest among all the men who have come to his knowledge, Montaigne names three, and the first is Homer. He will not settle whether Virgil might equal Homer in his own art; he understands only one of them. Still Virgil draws body and matter from one touch of the Iliad, and Homer is guide and teacher. Blind, poor, and living before the sciences were reduced into rule, Homer instructed those who later established governments, carried on wars, and wrote of religion or philosophy. His words, according to Aristotle, are the only words that have motion and action. Alexander, finding a rich cabinet among Darius's spoils, reserved it to keep his Homer in, and called him the most faithful counsellor in military affairs. Alcibiades boxed the ear of a man who pretended to learning and had no Homer in the house. Seven Grecian cities contended for his birth. Children are still called Hector and Achilles. Mohammed II, writing to Pope Pius II, claimed common descent from the Trojans and a duty to revenge the blood of Hector.

The second is Alexander. He began his enterprises young, with small means, and by three-and-thirty had passed victorious through the habitable earth. Fortune favoured hazardous, even rash, exploits. Montaigne lists justice, temperance, liberality, truth in his word, love toward his own people, and humanity toward those he overcame. He also names the sallies that cannot be well excused: the ruin of Thebes and Persepolis, the murder of Menander and of Ephistion's physician, the massacre of Persian prisoners and of Cossian children. As to Clytus, the fault was more than redeemed. It was ingeniously said that he had his virtues from Nature, his vices from Fortune. Caesar alone could make Montaigne doubtful in the choice. They were two fires, or two torrents, overrunning the world by several ways. Caesar's ambition, even if more moderate, still had the ruin of his country and mischief to the world for its object, so the balance inclines to Alexander.

The third, and in Montaigne's opinion the most excellent, is Epaminondas. Of glory he has not near so much as the other two. Of valour planted by wisdom in a regular soul, he had all that could be imagined. The Greeks pronounced him the greatest man of their nation. Never any man knew so much and spoke so little; when he did speak, never any man spoke better. In manners and conscience he surpassed all who undertook the management of affairs, and comes not short of Socrates himself. Innocence in this man is sovereign, constant, and uniform; in Alexander it appears subaltern, uncertain, and variable. Antiquity finds in other captains some peculiar quality that illustrates the name; in this man only a full and equal virtue throughout, whether in peace or war. Montaigne looks upon the obstinate poverty as a little too scrupulous to imitate. Scipio Aemilianus might be put in the other scale. For a gentleman of civilian manners and moderate ambition, Alcibiades has the richest life Montaigne knows. Epaminondas declared that the greatest satisfaction of his whole life was the contentment he gave his father and mother by the victory at Leuctra. He did not think it lawful, even to restore the liberty of his country, to kill a man without knowing a cause, which made him cold in Pelopidas's enterprise for the relief of Thebes. He held that men in battle ought to spare a friend on the contrary side. After he had forced the Lacedaemonians at the pass near Corinth, he contented himself with charging through them without pursuing to the utmost. The Boeotians took his commission of general for that humanity, then had, for shame, to restore it. Victory attended him like a shadow wherever he went. Homer still feeds children their names. Alexander's medals still passed as luck-charms after death. The prosperity of Epaminondas's country, derived from him, died with him.

Amplified Discussion
Why We Miss the Best People

Montaigne's ranking reveals a blind spot that still haunts us today: we're terrible at recognising sustainable excellence. We notice Homer because creativity is dramatic. We celebrate Alexander because conquest is visible. But Epaminondas? History barely remembers him, despite Montaigne calling him the greatest of all three. This pattern repeats everywhere. The nurse who prevents medical errors through careful attention gets no awards, while the surgeon who performs risky procedures makes headlines. The teacher who turns around struggling students works in anonymity, while the principal who talks about test scores gets promoted. The factory worker who mentors new hires and prevents accidents stays at the same pay grade, while the supervisor who cuts corners to meet quotas gets bonuses. We've built systems that reward the wrong things. We measure what's easy to count—publications, profits, followers—instead of what actually matters: character, sustainability, positive impact on others. This creates a vicious cycle where good people get discouraged and flashy people get encouraged to be even flashier. The Epaminondas types often stop trying for recognition and just focus on doing good work, which makes them even more invisible. Meanwhile, the Alexanders of the world learn that spectacle pays, so they double down on drama. How do we train ourselves to see and value the quiet excellence that actually holds our communities together?

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Keeping the Second List

A room will often rank the person who made the most noise, then treat that ranking as if it were a measurement of the person. Montaigne puts Epaminondas first for a full and equal virtue throughout, Homer for words that have motion and action, and Alexander for a fortune so large that medals still passed as luck-charms after death, while Thebes's prosperity died with the one equal man. When you next name someone great, write two lists: what luck, office, or parade inflated, and what would still command respect if those were stripped away, and keep only the second list when you decide whom to copy.

Lessons

PracticeWhen you next name someone great, write two lists: what luck, office, or parade inflated, and what would still command respect if those were stripped away, and keep only the second list when you decide whom to copy.

Psych reading

The Aftermath Rank

We treat noise, luck, and office as if they were character, then discover too late that the work could not stand without the parade.

In the mind

We rank by volume while the person is still in the room, then we are surprised when the work collapses the week they leave. The pattern is to treat noise, luck, and office as if they were character, so the list of people we copy is a list of parades. A team that cannot name what would still stand without the title, the grant, or the winning streak is already living on borrowed fortune. Navigation means keeping a second list: what craft and conduct would still command respect if the parade were stripped away. When you can name this pattern, predict where a luck-inflated ranking leads, and adjust before you commit, you have a map for the next time the same pressure appears.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors