Tacitus reports that amongst certain barbarian kings, when they would make a firm obligation, they join their right hands close to one another and intertwist their thumbs. When, by force of straining, the blood appears in the ends, they lightly prick them with some sharp instrument and mutually suck them. Physicians say that the thumbs are the master fingers of the hand, and that their Latin etymology is derived from pollere. The Greeks called them another hand, and the Latins sometimes take the word in this sense for the whole hand.
It was at Rome a signification of favour to depress and turn in the thumbs, and of disfavour to elevate and thrust them outward. The populace, with inverted thumbs, kill all that come before them. The Romans exempted from war all such as were maimed in the thumbs, as having no more sufficient strength to hold their weapons. Augustus confiscated the estate of a Roman knight who had maliciously cut off the thumbs of two young children he had, to excuse them from going into the armies. Before him, the Senate, in the time of the Italic war, condemned Caius Vatienus to perpetual imprisonment and confiscated all his goods for having purposely cut off the thumb of his left hand to exempt himself from that expedition.
Someone Montaigne has forgotten, having won a naval battle, cut off the thumbs of all his vanquished enemies to render them incapable of fighting and of handling the oar. The Athenians also caused the thumbs of the Aeginatans to be cut off, to deprive them of the superiority in the art of navigation. In Lacedaemon, pedagogues chastised their scholars by biting their thumbs.
Montaigne's thumb essay reveals something profound about how power actually works: it's not just about force or money, but about shared agreements to let certain symbols carry weight. The Roman crowd could spare or kill a gladiator with a thumb gesture because everyone agreed that gesture meant something. Today, we live surrounded by similar symbolic currencies that we rarely examine. A medical professional's white coat grants instant authority. A corner office communicates status. A verification checkmark on social media signals legitimacy. These symbols work because we collectively agree they mean something, but that agreement isn't natural or inevitable—it's constructed and maintained. The most interesting question becomes: which symbolic games are worth playing? Some serve us; others trap us. A nurse might need to master the symbolic language of hospital hierarchy to advocate effectively for patients. But recognising it as symbolic—rather than natural—preserves the ability to choose when to participate and when to resist. The thumb teaches us that power often operates through the smallest details, and that consciousness about these details gives us strategic options. When we can name the symbolic currencies operating around us, we can navigate them more skillfully rather than being unconsciously controlled by them.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion