Montaigne fancies a mind exactly balanced betwixt two equal desires. It can never pitch upon either, because the choice and application would show an inequality of esteem. Set betwixt the bottle and the ham, with an equal appetite to drink and to eat, there would be no remedy: the person must die of thirst and hunger. The Stoics, asked whence the soul elects among a great number of identical crowns, answer that the movement is extraordinary and irregular, entering by a foreign, accidental, and fortuitous impulse.
Montaigne would rather say that nothing presents itself wherein there is not some difference, however little. Sight or touch always finds a choice that, though it be imperceptible, tempts and attracts. Whoever presupposes a packthread equally strong throughout finds it utterly impossible it should break, for where will the breaking begin? That it should break altogether is not in nature.
He then joins geometric propositions that conclude the contained to be greater than the containing, the centre to be as great as its circumference, and two lines incessantly approaching each other which yet can never meet. He adds the philosopher's stone and the quadrature of the circle, where reason and the effect stand so opposite. Those puzzles second Pliny's saying that it is only certain that there is nothing certain, and that nothing is more miserable or more proud than man. The mind that waits for a perfect tie has not yet moved.
Montaigne lived in an age when religious and philosophical authorities promised absolute truth, yet he noticed how often people froze when faced with equal options. Today, we're drowning in information that promises to help us make 'optimal' decisions—from career paths to lunch choices. We have apps to rate restaurants, websites to compare every product, endless reviews for every service. Yet this abundance often makes us more paralyzed, not less. The nurse who spends her entire break researching the 'healthiest' meal option, then grabs vending machine chips because she ran out of time. The parent who delays enrolling their child in activities because no program seems perfect, so the kid misses the whole season. We've confused having more data with making better choices. Montaigne suggests something radical: those tiny preferences we feel but can't fully explain—the slight pull toward one option over another—might be more reliable than all our research. Our instincts incorporate information our conscious minds can't process. The question isn't whether we can make perfect choices (we can't), but whether we can trust ourselves enough to make good enough choices and adjust as we go. What if the goal isn't finding the one right answer, but developing confidence in our ability to navigate whatever we choose?
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion