LIVE
OCD← Home
The Essays of Montaigne cover
1580
The Essays of Montaigne
Michel de Montaigne · The Inconsistency of Our Actions
Chapter 58
Ch. 57
Reading
Ch. 58
Ch. 59
Loading audio...
0:000:00

Those who make it their business to oversee human actions find nothing so perplexing as reconciling them, for they commonly contradict one another so strangely that it seems impossible they should proceed from one and the same person. The younger Marius is one while a son of Mars and another a son of Venus. Pope Boniface VIII entered his Papacy like a fox, behaved himself in it like a lion, and died like a dog. Who could believe it the same Nero, the perfect image of all cruelty, who, having a condemned man's sentence brought to him to sign, cried out that he had never been taught to write, so much it went to his heart to condemn a man to death. Irresolution appears to Montaigne the most common and manifest vice of our nature. The player Publius said it is evil counsel that will admit no change. Authors still try to make of us any constant and solid contexture. They choose a general air of a man and impute whatever will not bend to dissimulation. Augustus has escaped them: his variety was so continual that he slipped away undecided from the most daring critics. Montaigne can more hardly believe a man's constancy than any other virtue. From all antiquity it is hard to pick out a dozen men who have formed their lives to one certain course. We never meditate what we would have till the instant we have a mind to have it. We change like that little creature which receives its colour from what it is laid upon. We do not go, we are driven. Empedocles observed the Agrigentines giving themselves up to delights as if every day were their last, and building as if they were to live for ever. In the younger Cato the judgment would not be hard: one step leads to all the rest. With us every particular action requires a particular judgment.

During the civil disorders of the kingdom, Montaigne was told of a maid, hard by where he then was, who threw herself from a window to avoid being forced by a common soldier quartered in the house. She was not killed, tried to cut her own throat, wounded herself, and, embrued in her own blood, appeared another Lucretia. He has since been very well assured that both before and after she was not so difficult a piece. Antigonus took a soldier into favour for his valour, had him cured of a long inward disease, then found him much more coldly at work. Yourself, sir, the man said, by having eased me of the pains that made me weary of my life. Lucullus's soldier, having been rifled by the enemy, performed a brave exploit in revenge, then flatly refused the next dangerous enterprise: employ some miserable plundered soldier. Chasan, rated by Mahomet for behaving ill against the Hungarians, rushed alone with a scimitar into the first body of the enemy and was cut to pieces. Montaigne will not call that established valour so much as a sudden despite. The man you saw yesterday so adventurous and brave may be as great a poltroon the next: anger, necessity, company, wine, or the sound of the trumpet had roused his spirits. Some have believed man has two souls. For his own part, the puff of every accident carries Montaigne along. He gives his soul sometimes one face and sometimes another: bashful, insolent; chaste, lustful; lying, true. Distinguo is the most universal member of his logic. He has nothing to say of himself entirely, simply, and solidly, without mixture and confusion.

One gallant action, therefore, ought not to conclude a man valiant. If it were a habit of valour and not a sally, he would be equally resolute alone as in company, in a sickness in his bed as in a wound in the field. We should not then see the same man charge into a breach with brave assurance and afterwards torment himself like a woman for the loss of a trial at law or the death of a child. The action is commendable, not the man. No valour is more extreme in its kind than Alexander's, yet it is of but one kind: his fear of conspiracy, his superstition, and the excess of his penitence for the murder of Clytus all mark the unevenness. All we perform is a cento of several pieces. Virtue cannot be followed but for herself. To make a right judgment of a man, we are long and very observantly to follow his trace. No one lays down a certain design for his life. We deliberate only by pieces. The archer ought first to know at what he is to aim. No wind serves him who addresses his voyage to no certain port. Montaigne will not acquiesce in the judgment that Sophocles was fit to manage domestic affairs because someone had read one of his tragedies, nor in the Parians who appointed the best farmers as new magistrates of Miletus, concluding that private husbandry proved public care. We are all lumps, and there is as much difference betwixt us and ourselves as betwixt us and others. Since ambition can teach valour, and even Venus can inflate boys and virgins with boldness, the understanding must penetrate the soul and discover by what springs the motion is guided. That being a high and hazardous undertaking, Montaigne could wish that fewer would attempt it.

Amplified Discussion
Why Consistency is Overrated

We live in a culture obsessed with authenticity and consistency. Social media demands we present a coherent personal brand. Job interviews ask us to describe our core values. We judge politicians for flip-flopping and friends for being two-faced. But Montaigne suggests this expectation is not just unrealistic—it's inhuman. Think about your own day: Are you the same person dealing with your boss as you are tucking your kids into bed? The same person stuck in traffic as you are helping a neighbour? Of course not. Different situations activate different parts of us. The exhausted nurse who snaps at her family isn't fake—she's human, operating under different pressures than when she's gently caring for patients. The friend who's generous with time but stingy with money isn't contradictory—they're responding to different resources and contexts. Maybe the real wisdom isn't achieving perfect consistency, but recognising these patterns in ourselves and others. When we stop demanding that people be the same in every situation, we can start seeing the beautiful complexity of human nature. We can build better relationships, make more realistic plans, and extend grace when people disappoint us. What if inconsistency isn't a bug in human nature, but a feature that helps us adapt and survive?

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Following the Trace Past One Act

One brave afternoon is enough to write someone down as a certain kind of person. Montaigne says one gallant action ought not to conclude a man valiant, because if he were brave indeed he would be always so, and Lucullus's plundered soldier refused the next danger once the purse was back. Before you trust a reputation from one heroic day, write what that person does in the next ordinary week when the trumpet is silent, and keep only the pattern that repeats.

Lessons

PracticeBefore you trust a reputation from one heroic day, write what that person does in the next ordinary week when the trumpet is silent, and keep only the pattern that repeats.

Psych reading

The One-Act Verdict

A person reads one gallant or shameful action as a finished nature, then cannot account for the next hour when circumstance, not character, did the work.

In the mind

A person awards a whole character from one impressive scene and then feels cheated when the next scene will not match. Hiring, friendship, and public reputation all run on that shortcut. Montaigne will not allow it. The younger Marius is Mars then Venus. Nero weeps that he learned to write. A civil-war maid looks like Lucretia in her blood and is not so difficult before or after. Lucullus's plundered soldier refuses the next danger once the purse is back. Distinguo is Montaigne's logic: he has nothing to say of himself simply. Navigation means following the trace across ordinary hours, not concluding valour from one sally. When you can name this pattern, predict where it leads, and adjust before you commit, you have a map for the next time the same pressure appears.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors