Montaigne opens by handing his formless fancies to the judgments of the Catholic Apostolic and Roman Church, into which he was born and in which he will die. He still ventures. God has prescribed a form of prayer word by word from His own mouth, and Montaigne has ever thought Christians ought to have the Lord's Prayer in more frequent use than they yet have. At table, at rising, at bed, in every action where prayer is used, he would have that prayer always in the mouth, if not alone then at least always. The Church may lengthen and diversify prayers for instruction, but the people should keep returning to the one that already holds every necessary petition. It is the only prayer he uses in all places and conditions. He repeats it instead of changing, and so has no other so entirely by heart.
The error that next comes to him is calling God into every design, just or otherwise, as if His name were a tool for whatever the hour requires. Plato, in his Laws, names three injurious beliefs about the gods: that there are none, that they ignore our affairs, and that they never refuse vows, offerings, and sacrifices. God's justice and His power are inseparable, so it is vain to invoke His power in an unjust cause. The soul must be pure at the moment of prayer, or the speaker presents God the rods with which to chastise him. Montaigne will not applaud those so frequent on their knees unless the actions nearest the prayer show amendment. He is scandalised to see a man cross himself thrice at the Benedicite and as often at Grace, then give the other hours to malice, avarice, and injustice: one hour to God, the rest to the devil, as if by composition. A man once confessed to him that he had practised a religion he thought damnable, only to keep the credit of his employments. Trades whose very essence is vicious sit in the same split. The Church, he thinks, is right to interdict the promiscuous use of the Psalms. That poesy is too holy for a prentice in his shop or for a Holy Book tumbled about a hall or kitchen. Translating scripture into every vulgar tongue, he fears, carries more danger than utility. A Greek historian censures an age that lets every mechanic expound the mysteries. Emperor Andronicus threatened to throw courtiers into the river if they would not drop a theological quarrel in his palace. Yet women and children now lecture the oldest men about ecclesiastical laws.
Xenophon warned that we should call upon God the more seldom because it is so hard to compose the soul to the calm a prayer requires. Forgive us our trespasses, as we forgive them that trespass against us, presents a soul free from rancour, yet men still invite God into unjust designs. The covetous man prays for superfluous riches. The thief thanks Him for an easy throat-cutting. At the door they are about to storm they fall to prayers for success. Marguerite, Queen of Navarre, tells of a young prince who never passed a church on the way to lie with an advocate's wife without kneeling to pray. A cut-purse calling a magistrate, or a liar swearing by God, is the same alliance. Few men dare publish the prayers they actually make. Horace's petitioner asks fair Laverna for the talent to deceive and to seem just. The gods punished Oedipus by granting his prayer that his children settle the throne by arms, and he lived to see himself taken at his word. We treat prayer as jargon, hoping the sound and jingle of words will buy remission while the soul stays contaminated. Neither the gods nor good men, says Plato, will accept the present of a wicked man. Horace's small cake from a pure hand still sits on the altar. Whether anyone will bring that hand, and not only the words, remains the open test.
Montaigne identified something we see everywhere today: people who mistake performing virtue for practicing it. He watched Christians cross themselves while plotting harm, treating prayer like a magical ritual that balanced out their moral failures. Sound familiar? We see this pattern in corporate executives who speak eloquently about company values while cutting worker benefits, politicians who champion family values while destroying their own families, and activists who preach tolerance while attacking anyone who disagrees with them. The mechanism is always the same: we compartmentalize our lives into sacred and secular zones, believing that ritual observance or righteous language can balance moral failure. Social media has made this worse—we curate virtuous online personas while living contradictory private lives, mistaking the post for the practice. Montaigne's insight cuts deep because it forces us to examine our own gaps. Where do we perform virtue while avoiding its actual demands? The healthcare worker who posts about compassion while being cruel to difficult patients. The parent who lectures about honesty while lying about family problems. The teacher who champions education while phoning it in with students who need them most. Montaigne suggests the solution isn't more performance but less—pray less frequently but more authentically, speak fewer noble words but live them more fully.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion