Montaigne will pardon people for taking their own manners as the only rule of perfection. Almost all men, not only the vulgar, walk the beaten road their ancestors trod. He is content if they look on Fabricius or Laelius as barbarous because those Romans are neither clothed nor fashioned according to our mode. What he finds fault with is the next step: they let present usage blind them so far that every month they alter their opinion if custom requires it, and they vary their judgment even in their own particular concern.
When they wore the busk of their doublets up as high as their breasts, they stiffly maintained it was in its proper place. Some years after, it slipped down betwixt their thighs, and they laughed at the former fashion as uneasy and intolerable. The fashion now in use condemns both with so much resolution that a man would think a certain madness had crept in and infatuated their understandings. Change is so prompt that the despised forms must come back into vogue, and the same judgment, in fifteen or twenty years, takes up half a dozen contrary opinions. There is not any of us so discreet who is not gulled by this contradiction and blinded in both external and internal sight.
He musters old customs so the continual variation of human things may settle judgment more firmly. Romans fought with rapier and cloak, as we do, and stopped passengers on the road for an account of who they were. They bathed stark naked in mixed and perfumed water, ate lying upon beds, kissed in salutation as the Venetians do, and kept snow in summer to cool their wine. Cato, after Pharsalia, sat to his meals as a mark of austere grief. Pasicles, greeting a great man, laid his hand on the private parts instead of the knee and asked if that part was not the man's own as well. We match them in will for magnificence and vice, Montaigne says, but we lack their vigour of soul for either great good or great ill. Argian and Roman ladies mourned in white, as ours did formerly, and as they should do still if he governed the point. There are whole books on the subject. The next fashion is already waiting to call this one madness.
Montaigne exposes something uncomfortable: we don't just follow social trends, we become convinced they represent universal truth. Think about how this operates today. Healthcare workers defend protocols that change yearly, each time with genuine conviction. Parents enforce rules they rebelled against as teenagers, certain their current approach is obviously correct. Social media amplifies this pattern—we champion causes that shift with algorithmic winds, forgetting our previous passionate positions. The mechanism is simple but powerful: social pressure creates certainty, and certainty erases memory of alternatives. Montaigne's Roman examples—eating lying down, bathing naked together, using sponge-sticks for toilet paper—seem bizarre to us, but Romans probably thought our customs equally strange. The point isn't that all customs are equal, but that most social rules are more arbitrary than we realise. When we mistake current fashions for eternal truths, we lose the ability to think independently. The navigation strategy involves practicing intellectual archaeology: regularly asking what you believed five years ago and why you changed. Use the 'Roman test'—when you feel certain about a social rule, imagine explaining it to someone from a completely different culture. Most importantly, distinguish between principles and practices. Core values remain constant, but their expressions shift constantly. The question becomes: Are you following the crowd or making reasoned choices?
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion