Montaigne names the solicitude of reputation the most universally received folly of the world. People abandon riches, peace, life, and health to chase a vain phantom that has neither body nor hold. He quotes Tasso: fame charms proud mortals, yet is only an echo, a dream, the shadow of a dream that vanishes at every breath. Even the philosophers are among the last to disengage. The humour is so deeply rooted that he dare not say anyone ever clearly discharged himself of it. Cicero's jab is that those who most controvert glory still want the books they write about it to visit the light under their own names, and seek to derive glory from seeming to despise it. All other things are communicable and fall into commerce. We lend our goods and stake our lives for friends. To communicate a man's honour, and to robe another with a man's own glory, is very rarely seen.
And yet he has examples. Catulus Luctatius, in the Cimbrian war, having done all he could to make flying soldiers face about, ran away with the rest and counterfeited the coward so they might seem to follow their captain rather than fly from the enemy. He abandoned his own reputation to cover their shame. When Charles V resolved on the Provence expedition of 1537, Antonio de Leva stiffly opposed it in council, though he believed it would redound to the emperor's honour, so that the entire glory of the resolution should be attributed to his master. Archileonida, mother of Brasidas, rejected Thracian ambassadors who said her son had not left his like, and sent the praise back to the city: Sparta has many citizens both greater and of greater worth. At Crecy the young Prince of Wales held the vanguard. Lords, overmatched, sent to King Edward for relief. The king asked if his son still lived and sat on horseback. Told that he did, Edward would neither go nor send. To ride in now would do the boy wrong and deprive him of the honour of a battle he had so long and so bravely sustained. Livy supplies the reason people give: what is last added seems to have accomplished the whole affair.
Many at Rome said the greatest of Scipio's acts were in part due to Laelius, whose constant practice was to advance Scipio's grandeur without any care of his own. Theopompus of Sparta, told the republic could not miscarry because he knew so well how to command, answered that it was rather because the people knew so well how to obey. The Bishop of Beauvais fought beside Philip Augustus at Bouvines, reduced several of the enemy with his own hand, then delivered them to the first gentleman he met, and fought with a mace so he might kill but not wound. A man of Montaigne's time, reproached by the king for laying hands on a priest, stiffly denied it: the meaning was, he had only cudgelled and kicked him. Glory here can be lent, redirected, or gamed with a mace. The next honour still has to choose which of those three it will be.
Montaigne observed something that remains painfully relevant: the people most obsessed with getting recognition are often the least respected. In his time, it was generals and nobles. Today, it's the coworker who sends emails copying the boss to highlight their contributions, the supervisor who takes credit for their team's ideas, or the colleague who throws others under the bus to look competent. The psychology hasn't changed in 400 years. What Montaigne understood, and what modern research confirms, is that desperate status-seeking signals insecurity. When we're constantly protecting our image, others sense our neediness and pull away. But when leaders deliberately share credit or even absorb blame that isn't entirely theirs, something powerful happens. They signal confidence and genuine strength. The Roman general who pretended to be a coward so his fleeing soldiers could save face wasn't just being noble - he was being strategic. By protecting their dignity, he earned loyalty that lasted far beyond that battle. The same dynamic plays out in every workplace. The manager who says 'This was Sarah's brilliant idea' builds a team that will move mountains. The one who says 'I came up with this approach' gets compliance at best. Montaigne's examples show us that real influence comes from elevating others, not diminishing them. The question becomes: are we secure enough in ourselves to make others look good?
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion