Montaigne stacks three victories that refuse a clean face. Antigonus is displeased when his son presents the newly slain head of King Pyrrhus, and he weeps. Rene, Duke of Lorraine, appears in mourning at the funeral of Charles, Duke of Burgundy, whom he has himself defeated. At D'Auray, Count Montfort meets the dead body of Charles de Blois and is much afflicted. We must not presently cry out, Montaigne says, that every mixed look is a mask. When Pompey's head is presented to Caesar, the histories say he turned away his face as from a sad and unpleasing object. Long intelligence in public affairs, community of fortunes, and near alliance sit behind that turn. Lucan may call the tears forced, and Publius Syrus may say an heir's tears are smiles, and Montaigne grants that visor and disguise cover a great part of our actions. Still, in judging these accidents, we have to consider how souls are agitated with divers passions. One motion overrules the rest, yet those of less authority can sally in turn.
Children who follow nature often laugh and cry at the same thing. A man who has set his heart on a journey still puts foot in the stirrup with a sad and cloudy countenance. Modest virgins are forced from about their mothers' necks towards their husbands, whatever Catullus says about feigned tears. Montaigne rattles his man with downright real curses, then, the heat being over, is ready to do him good and turns the leaf. He can call him calf and coxcomb and, presently after, an honest fellow, without giving himself the lie. No one quality engrosses us purely and universally. Whoever sees him one while cold and presently very fond towards his wife, and believes either is counterfeited, is an ass. Nero, taking leave of the mother he is sending to be drowned, is still struck with horror and pity.
The sun darts new rays so thick we cannot perceive the intermission; just so the soul variously and imperceptibly darts out her passions. Artabanus comes by surprise upon his nephew Xerxes and chides the sudden alteration of his countenance. Xerxes has been considering the immeasurable greatness of his forces passing over the Hellespont: first a palpitation of joy at so many millions under his command, then, in the same instant, the thought that of so many lives, within a century at most, not one would be left, and he knits his brows and grows sad, even to tears. We can pursue revenge with singular contentment and still weep, not for the victory. Nothing in the victory has altered; the soul looks upon things with another eye, for everything has many faces and several aspects. If we would make one continued thing of this succession of passions, we deceive ourselves. When Timoleon laments the murder he committed upon mature and generous deliberation, he does not lament the liberty restored to his country, and he does not lament the tyrant. He laments his brother. One part of his duty is performed. Montaigne asks that we give him leave to perform the other.
Montaigne lived in a world that demanded clear loyalties—you were Catholic or Protestant, loyal to this king or that one. Yet he discovered that human hearts refuse such neat categories. Today's world has the same pressure for emotional clarity. Social media rewards simple reactions—love it or hate it, celebrate or condemn. We're expected to have clean feelings about messy situations. A nurse should feel only compassion for patients, never frustration. A parent should feel only joy at their child's graduation, never grief at their growing independence. A worker should feel only gratitude for employment, never resentment about unfair conditions. But Montaigne reveals this emotional simplicity as artificial. Real humans contain multitudes. The warrior who kills an enemy can simultaneously feel victory and remorse. The bride can love her new husband while mourning her old life. The promoted employee can feel proud and sad. This isn't emotional immaturity—it's emotional sophistication. When we deny our complexity, we lose access to crucial information. The grief in Arthur's promotion tells him what he values. The frustration in the nurse's compassion signals when boundaries are needed. Our contradictory emotions aren't problems to solve but wisdom to decode. They reveal what matters to us, what we're losing, what we're gaining, and what we need to protect. The question becomes: what do your contradictory emotions tell you about what you truly value?
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion