Montaigne, in a shivering season, disputes with himself whether the newly found nations go naked because the air is hot, as Europeans say of the Indians and Moors, or because nakedness is mankind's original fashion. Men of understanding, he says, separate natural law from human invention by looking at the world's general polity, where nothing can be counterfeit. Other living things arrive furnished; Lucretius names skin, hair, shells, and bark. Montaigne will not believe we alone come into the world defective, unable to live without external aid. Nature would have clothed us too. We put that covering out the way artificial light puts out daylight: borrowed forms and fashions have destroyed our own. Custom, not climate, makes nudity look impossible. Nations without clothing live under the same temperature as France, and some in colder air. Eyes, mouth, nose, and ears stay bare already. Country labourers, like older French, still go with breasts and bellies open. Had petticoats and breeches been a necessity of birth, nature would have thickened those parts as she thickened the finger-ends and the soles of the feet.
The distance between Montaigne's habit and a country labourer's is greater, he finds, than the distance between that labourer and a man covered only in skin. Turks go naked for devotion. A beggar in his shirt in the depth of winter, as brisk as a man muffled to the ears in furs, is asked how he endures it. You go with your face bare, he answers; I am all face. The Duke of Florence's fool tells his warmly wrapped master to put on all his clothes at once. The same training shows in bare heads: Massinissa will not cover his in storm; Herodotus finds Egyptian skulls harder than Persian ones because one people went shaved from infancy while the other wore biggins and turbans; Caesar and Hannibal march uncovered in rain.
Montaigne cannot endure to go unbuttoned or untied; his neighbouring labourers would think themselves in chains if they were so braced. Near Piacenza the Romans charge with blood congealed, while Hannibal spreads fires through his camp and has oil distributed so his men may anoint themselves against the freezing wind. As far as clothes go, the King of Mexico changes his apparel four times a day and never puts it on again, giving away what he leaves off, and no dish of his table is served twice. Custom has shut the avenues so carefully that the essay has to trespass to speak, and the trespass still leaves Montaigne buttoned in a world where other bodies have learned a different skin.
Montaigne's insight about clothing reveals something profound about modern consumer culture. We've created a society where yesterday's luxuries become today's necessities, and each generation grows up thinking their comfort level is the baseline for human survival. The beggar who says 'I am all face' when asked how he stays warm points to a truth we've forgotten: our tolerance for discomfort is largely mental, and our bodies adapt to whatever we consistently demand. This isn't about returning to primitive life - it's about recognising how comfort can become a prison. When we need specific conditions to function, we become fragile. The worker who can't start their day without expensive coffee, the family that panics when the internet goes down, the student who can't focus without perfect silence - these aren't character flaws, they're predictable results of conditioning. Indigenous peoples Montaigne describes weren't superhuman; they simply hadn't trained themselves to need what they didn't have. The real question isn't whether we should give up modern conveniences, but whether we're building resilience alongside comfort. Are we raising children who can adapt when circumstances change, or are we creating adults who crumble when their artificial needs aren't met? The difference between thriving and surviving often comes down to this: can you function when your usual supports aren't available?
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion