LIVE
OCD← Home
The Essays of Montaigne cover
1580
The Essays of Montaigne
Michel de Montaigne · When Experts Overstep Their Bounds
Chapter 16
Ch. 15
Reading
Ch. 16
Ch. 17
Loading audio...
0:000:00

On his travels Montaigne makes it a custom to learn from whoever sits with him, and to put each companion upon the subject they can actually speak of. He quotes the Italian proverb: let the sailor talk of winds, the cowherd of oxen, the soldier of wounds, the shepherd of flocks. Most people do the opposite. They would rather be prating of another man's province than their own, thinking it so much new reputation acquired. Archidamus jeers Pertander for quitting the glory of an excellent physician to gain the repute of a very bad poet. Caesar grows large on bridges and engines of war and stays succinct on his own valour and military conduct. His exploits already prove him a great captain; he still wants to be thought an excellent engineer to boot. The elder Dionysius, another great captain, takes great pains to win a name by poetry and is never cut out for a poet. A lawyer, shown a study furnished with books of his own faculty, ignores them and descants instead on a barricade on the winding stair, a thing soldiers pass every day without notice. By this course, Montaigne says, a man never arrives at perfection in anything.

When he reads histories he first asks what kind of man the author is. From a physician he will take wounds and the temperature of the air; from a soldier, the actions he was personally engaged in; from an ambassador, the manner of a negotiation. That is why he lingers on a passage in Monsieur de Langey. Charles V, speaking in the Consistory at Rome before the Bishop of Macon and Monsieur du Velly, mixes injurious expressions to the dishonour of France. He says that if his own captains were not men of another fidelity, he would go with a rope about his neck and sue the King for mercy. He also challenges the King to fight him in his shirt, with rapier and poignard, in a boat. The ambassadors send a despatch and conceal the greatest part, particularly those last two passages. Montaigne wonders that a servant should have power to hide what his master ought to hear. The liberty of selecting, disposing, judging, and concluding belongs to the man who gives the law, not to the man who only receives it. He would not be so served in his little concerns.

Yet he will not turn every act of judgment into a virtue. People slip the collar of command on any pretence, and no utility from the wit or valour of those they employ should be dearer to a superior than sincere obedience. P. Crassus, consul in Asia, orders a Greek engineer to fetch the greater of two masts at Athens for a battery. The engineer, trusting his own science, brings the lesser mast, which the rules of art say is more proper. Crassus hears the reasons with patience and has him well whipped, valuing discipline more than the work in hand. Ambassadors, though, are never held to so confined a line. They do not simply execute; they form and model their master's pleasure. Montaigne has known men of command checked for obeying the express words of the king's letters rather than the necessity of the affairs in hand. Men of understanding still condemn the Persian custom of giving lieutenants so little rein that every new difficulty must wait on further commands, a delay that has often prejudiced affairs across a vast dominion. And Crassus, writing to a man whose profession it was to know those things, and telling him the use of the mast, did he not seem to invite that better judgment?

Amplified Discussion
Why Success Makes Us Stupid

Montaigne identified something we see everywhere today: the moment people get good at one thing, they start thinking they're good at everything. It's not arrogance exactly—it's a weird side effect of competence. When you master something difficult, your brain generalises that success. The nurse who saves lives thinks she can redesign hospital systems. The mechanic who fixes engines becomes the neighbourhood's unofficial marriage counselor. Social media has made this epidemic. Everyone's an expert on politics, medicine, and economics while their actual skills gather dust. But here's what Montaigne understood that we've forgotten: expertise is narrow and deep, not broad and shallow. The sailor who tries to be a philosopher isn't just wasting time—he's abandoning the very thing that makes him valuable. In our rush to have opinions about everything, we're neglecting the few things we actually know how to do well. The most successful people aren't the ones with opinions about everything; they're the ones who know their lane and stay in it, while being genuinely curious about others' expertise. When we stop pretending to know everything, we can finally get really good at something.

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Sending the Uncut Dispatch

The person who carries hard news often trims it first, so the listener will not do something rash. French ambassadors, sending a despatch after Charles V insulted the King in the Consistory at Rome, concealed the greatest part, including a challenge to fight in a boat. When you carry news upward this week, write the whole message first and leave the choosing to the person who must act.

Lessons

PracticeThis week, when you carry news upward, write the uncut version first and leave the choosing to the person who must act.

Psych reading

The Edited Dispatch

When a messenger decides what the listener can handle, the person who must act is left ignorant, and the servant has quietly taken the choosing that belongs to the seat of command.

In the mind

People grab status by talking of a craft that is not theirs, then call the same appetite prudence when they edit news going upward. Montaigne first watches Caesar linger on bridges and a lawyer lecture on a stair barricade, then lingers on Langey's ambassadors, who hid Charles V's insults so the King would not take some extravagant resolution. The mechanism is usurpation dressed as care. A colleague speaks for a department they do not run; a deputy softens a report until the person in command decides blind. Crassus then whips the engineer who brought a technically better mast, because obedience can matter more than the clever fix. Ambassadors, though, are not held to that narrow line, and Crassus's own letter, stating the use of the mast, seemed to invite the judgment he later punished. Navigation means speaking from your own work, sending the whole dispatch when you are only the messenger, and asking whether the brief in front of you actually asked for your better judgment.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors