Valour has its bounds, Montaigne says, as other virtues do. Cross the line and the next step is vice: temerity, obstinacy, and folly. The confines are hard to see, which is why a man with too much of this heroic quality can walk into them unawares. From that thought comes a wartime custom: punish, even with death, those who obstinately defend a place that the rules of war do not call tenable. Otherwise hope of pardon would make every henroost resist and try to stop an army.
The Constable Monsieur de Montmorenci, ordered to cross the Ticino and quarter in the Faubourg St. Antonio, found a tower at the end of the bridge that endured a battery. He hanged every man inside for their labour. Later, on the Dauphin's Alpine expedition, the Castle of Villano fell by assault. The soldiers put all within to the sword except the governor and his ensign; Montmorenci had those two trussed up for the same reason. Captain Martin du Bellay, governor of Turin, did likewise with the governor of San Buono after that place was taken and its people cut to pieces.
Yet the strength or weakness of a fortress is always weighed against the force that attacks it. A man might reasonably despise two culverins and still be mad to stand a battery of thirty cannon. The greatness of the prince in the field, his reputation, and the respect due to him also enter the scale, and the scale can tip too far. A commander swollen with his own power may think no gate should dare shut against him, and put all to the sword while fortune lasts. Above ransom and mercy, then, take care not to fall into the hands of a judge who is both an enemy and already victorious.
Montaigne reveals something chilling about human nature: we don't just abuse power—we become addicted to it. His military commanders start with legitimate reasons to execute defenders of hopeless positions. It prevents endless, bloody sieges. But each successful use of force feeds their ego until they're massacring anyone who dares question them. The same pattern appears everywhere today. The supervisor who starts by enforcing safety rules but evolves into someone who writes people up for breathing wrong. The parent who begins with appropriate discipline but becomes controlling over every minor choice. The teacher who initially corrects disruptive behaviour but eventually humiliates students for asking questions. What makes this so dangerous is how it feels justified from the inside. The person wielding power always has reasons. They're maintaining standards, keeping people safe, ensuring respect. But Montaigne shows us the tell: when authority stops serving its original purpose and starts serving the ego of the person in charge. The key question isn't whether someone has the right to exercise power—it's whether they can still distinguish between necessary enforcement and personal domination. Can they admit when they're wrong? Do they escalate punishments for increasingly minor infractions? Do they take resistance as personal attacks? The most dangerous people aren't those who abuse power deliberately—they're those who abuse it while convinced they're doing the right thing.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion