LIVE
OCD← Home
The Essays of Montaigne cover
1580
The Essays of Montaigne
Michel de Montaigne · The Hidden Costs of Power
Chapter 101
Ch. 100
Reading
Ch. 101
Ch. 102
Loading audio...
0:000:00

We rail at greatness, Montaigne says, because we cannot attain it, yet to proclaim its defects is not absolute railing, since defects sit in all things, however beautiful. Greatness keeps a choice ordinary life does not: it can lower itself when it pleases, and a man does not fall from every height. He finds misfortunes hard to undergo, but a moderate measure of fortune, and the avoidance of greatness, a very easy matter. Even the glory of refusal may hide a worse ambition, because ambition never carries itself better than on obscure, unfrequented ways. He loves himself too well to wish for empire or royalty. When he thinks to grow greater, it is only a compelled and timorous advancement. He would rather, without lying, be third at Paris than first, and second or third in Perigord than first at Paris. His soul is timid enough that it measures good fortune by ease, not by height. Set Lucius Thorius Balbus, quiet, his own, dying with his sword in his hand, beside Marcus Regulus, exemplary and glorious: Cicero prefers Regulus. Montaigne could attain the first by use and only approach the second with veneration.

He disrelishes all dominion, whether active or passive. Otanes, one of seven with a right to the Persian throne, gave his claim to his competitors, by election or by lot, provided he and his might live in the empire out of all authority and subjection, the ancient laws excepted, as impatient of commanding as of being commanded. Worthily to discharge a king's office is, in Montaigne's opinion, the most painful employment in the world; he excuses more of their mistakes than men commonly do. Two Scottish authors, read a month ago, place the king worse than a carter, or some degrees above God. The incommodity he came to remark is this: in the trials we make against one another for honour, of body or of mind, sovereign greatness can have no true part. In childhood, those who exercised with him forbore their utmost because they found him unworthy of their full endeavour. That, he says, happens to princes daily. Brisson, running against Alexander, purposely missed his blow; Alexander rebuked him, but ought to have had him whipped.

Carneades said the sons of princes learned nothing right but to manage horses, because a horse, neither flatterer nor courtier, throws a king's son with no more ceremony than a porter's. Homer had to wound Venus at Troy so courage could be ascribed to her. Who does not share the hazard can claim no interest in the honour. Conceive a man accompanied with omnipotence and you overwhelm him: he must beg disturbance and opposition as an alms. It is to slide, not to go; to sleep, and not to live. The senate awarded Tiberius the prize of eloquence; he refused it, because a judgment so partial could give him no advantage even if just. Alexander's followers carried their heads on one side as he did. Dionysius's flatterers stumbled and overturned what was underfoot to show they were as purblind as he. Courtiers repudiated wives they loved because the master hated his. Favorinus yielded a word to the Emperor Adrian: would you not have him wiser than I, who commands thirty legions? Pollio would not write against Augustus, who has power to proscribe. Dionysius, unable to equal Philoxenus in poesy or Plato in discourse, condemned the one to the quarries and sent the other to be sold for a slave in Aegina. The horse still throws whom it will. The room that will not miss on purpose has not yet opened.

Amplified Discussion
The Loneliness Tax of Success

Montaigne identified something we still struggle with today: success often comes with a hidden tax—the loss of authentic relationships. When you become the boss, the expert, or the person everyone looks up to, you enter a world of performance where everyone has an agenda. Your former peers now see you as 'management.' Your subordinates tell you what they think you want to hear. Even friends start treating you differently because they know you have power they don't. This isn't just about CEOs or politicians—it happens to the nurse who becomes a supervisor, the mechanic who opens his own shop, or the teacher who becomes principal. The promotion you worked for creates a barrier between you and the very experiences that helped you grow: honest criticism, real competition, genuine struggle. Montaigne suggests this is why some people deliberately choose to be second-best in a place where the competition is real rather than first in a place where it's fake. The question isn't whether to seek success, but how to maintain authentic connections as you climb. How do you stay human when everyone starts treating you like a position rather than a person? How do you know when praise is real and when it's just people managing up? The loneliness at the top isn't inevitable—it's a choice about how you handle the power that comes with achievement.

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Ask Them to Stop Yielding

When a room starts letting you win, the win stops teaching you anything. Carneades says princes learn only to manage horses, because a horse throws a king's son with no more ceremony than a porter's. This week, pick one place your title makes people hold back, ask one person to stop yielding, and write what the contest looks like once they do.

Lessons

PracticeThis week, pick one place your title makes people hold back, ask one person to stop yielding, and write what the contest looks like once they do.

Psych reading

The Yielded Contest

When rank makes other people hold back, the person at the top stops receiving a real test, then mistakes the easy win for proof of quality.

In the mind

A room that wants something from you will often miss on purpose. Montaigne moves from Otanes refusing the Persian throne, through childhood partners who forbore their utmost, to Brisson missing his blow against Alexander and Carneades' horse, the one opponent that will not flatter. The mechanism is mistaking unopposed rank for virtue. A new title, a famous name, or a packed calendar can buy the same solitude: people laugh first, yield first, and leave you sliding rather than walking. Navigation means finding one arena where your place cannot cancel the contest, and noticing who still throws you. When you can name this pattern, predict where it leads, and adjust before you commit, you have a map for the next time the same pressure appears.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors