A Sunday in February, a year after Shaston. Sue holds up a letter at breakfast in the little house with Jude's name on it. The decree nisi in Phillotson versus Phillotson and Fawley has been made absolute. His own suit against Arabella finished a month or two earlier. Both were too insignificant for the papers. Now, he says, she can do what she likes. She has an uncomfortable feeling that her freedom was obtained under false pretences: they led the court to suppose what was not true of their life together. He says a marriage is dissolved when it is dissolved.
She puts on a joyful coloured gown. They strut arm in arm like any other engaged couple. He assumes they will marry after a decent interval. She has the same dread as always: an iron contract would extinguish their tenderness, as it did between their parents. She would rather live always as lovers and only meet by day. Licensed to be loved on the premises, she says, is horrible and sordid. He lectures her on women who play elusiveness. She does not like him so well today. He is too sermony. Now that she has nobody but him, she must have her own way in deciding how they will live.
They drop the subject for days. He letters cheap headstones in the backyard for neighbours who know what a cheap man Jude Fawley, Monumental Mason, is. She marks the letters full size and blacks them in. It is a lower craft than cathedral work. It is also the only arrangement under which she, who particularly wished to be no burden, can render any assistance.
Hardy wrote about Victorian marriage laws that trapped people in loveless unions, but Sue's real prison isn't legal—it's psychological. She's spent years blaming external forces for her unhappiness, and now that those barriers are gone, she faces a terrifying possibility: what if she gets everything she wants and it's still not enough? What if the problem was never the obstacles but her own capacity for satisfaction? This pattern transcends Hardy's era. Today's version might be the person who complains about being single but finds fatal flaws in every potential partner, or the employee who demands more responsibility then criticises every opportunity as 'not the right fit.' We create elaborate philosophical justifications for our avoidance—Sue calls it preserving romance, but it's really preserving the fantasy that perfect love exists somewhere just out of reach. The cruelest irony is that by avoiding commitment to protect love, we often destroy the very thing we're trying to preserve. Modern psychology recognises this as 'approach-avoidance conflict'—simultaneously wanting and fearing the same outcome. The person who gets the promotion they wanted then finds reasons to quit. The couple who finally gets engaged then starts fighting about wedding details. Hardy understood that sometimes the biggest obstacle to happiness isn't society or circumstances—it's our own inability to tolerate vulnerability. When we recognise this pattern in ourselves or others, we can start addressing the real fear instead of the manufactured obstacles.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion