Late that evening Bathsheba sits alone by the first fire of the season, with Fanny’s coffin in the next room and her husband not yet home. Liddy offers to sit up for him and says she is not afraid of Fanny. Bathsheba, in a sudden whisper, asks if she has heard anything strange said of Fanny, then bursts into tears. A few minutes later Liddy is back with what Maryann has just heard, whispered into her ear: that the coffin holds more than one body. Bathsheba says she does not believe it, since there is only one name on the lid, and turns to the fire so that Liddy cannot see her face. Hardy lets us see what Oak and Boldwood never guess. Bathsheba met the lonely woman on the road on Saturday night, and she has been working towards this fear for days.
She wants someone stronger to ask, and thinks of Gabriel. She walks down the lane in a cloak and sees him through his uncurtained window, reading, and later kneeling to pray in an upstairs room. She cannot knock. The calm of that little house is more than she can bear to look at. Back in the hall, she says to the door of the room where the coffin lies, “Would to God you would speak and tell me your secret, Fanny!” and then, slowly, “And I will.” She fetches a screw-driver from the lumber-closet. Hardy says she could never afterwards understand the mood that carried her through what followed. She uncovers the coffin and looks at Fanny and the child. Yellow hair frames Fanny’s face, and the curl in Troy’s watch needs no more explaining. In her heated mind the dead girl seems to have won. She hates her, is frightened at hating a dead woman, and, remembering Oak at his prayers, kneels by the coffin. When she rises she lays flowers from a vase around Fanny’s head.
Troy comes in and sees her there, and for a moment thinks someone in the house has died. She tries to push past him, but he holds her hand and walks her to the coffin. “Do you know her?” “I do.” “Is it she?” “It is.” He kneels and kisses Fanny, gently, as one would kiss a sleeping child. Bathsheba springs forward and cries, “Kiss me too, Frank,” the proud woman reduced to a child’s plea, and he pushes her away. He says he is a bad, black-hearted man, that the dead woman is more to him than Bathsheba ever was, and that but for her face he would have married Fanny. “In the sight of Heaven you are my very, very wife!” Bathsheba’s cry of despair fills the old house. “You are nothing to me,” Troy says, and she runs out of it.
Hardy shows us something profound about human psychology: sometimes not knowing feels more dangerous than knowing something terrible. Bathsheba opens a coffin because the whispers and uncertainty are driving her insane. She needs the truth, even if it destroys her marriage and sense of self. This pattern repeats constantly in modern life. The spouse who checks their partner's phone, knowing they might find evidence of an affair. The employee who digs into company records, risking their job to confirm suspicions of fraud. The adult child who demands family secrets about their parentage, even when relatives warn it will change everything. We tell ourselves we need to know for practical reasons, but often we're trying to regain control in a powerless situation. The uncertainty feels like torture, so we choose the pain of knowledge over the agony of doubt. But Hardy also shows us the cost. Once Bathsheba knows the truth about Fanny and Troy, she can't unknow it. The information doesn't give her power—it takes away her illusions and forces her to act. The question becomes: when is the desperate need to know actually about healing and moving forward, and when is it about feeding our anxiety? How do we build the support systems we need before we go looking for truths that might change everything?
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion