That same evening Gabriel is leaning on Coggan's gate when Bathsheba's gig creeps along the grass of the lane. Liddy asks questions about Bath, and Bathsheba answers them listlessly. Both mistress and horse look weary. The relief of seeing her safe is so great that Gabriel forgets every grave report. Boldwood passes, wishes him good night, and walks on towards her house with an apology in mind. He has kept to his garden since the meeting on the Yalbury road, and a kinder mood has come over him. He thinks she has only been to Liddy's. Liddy goes in and leaves him on the step, and the blind in the parlour comes down. "My mistress cannot see you, sir." He goes away unforgiven.
At ten, passing through the lower village, he sees the carrier's van pull up, and a scarlet form step down. It is Troy. Boldwood hurries home, comes back with a thick cudgel, and meets Troy leaving again with his carpet-bag. He does not preach. He offers a business deal. He knows about Fanny Robin, and Troy should marry her. If he leaves Weatherbury tonight, he will have fifty pounds now, Fanny fifty more, and five hundred on the wedding day. Hardy remarks that love adds emotion and takes away capacity: Boldwood knows nothing of where Fanny is. Troy agrees and takes the sovereigns. Then Bathsheba's footsteps come up the hill, and Troy whistles. "Frank, dearest," she calls, and tells him she has sent every servant away so that nobody will know of his visit. Boldwood listens, holding the bag. Troy mocks him. He cannot marry both women, he says, and he prefers Fanny, and Boldwood has made it worth his while. Boldwood seizes his throat and lets go, and within minutes he is begging Troy to marry Bathsheba instead and offering the money for that.
Troy leads him up to her door, slips inside, and puts the chain across. Through the gap he hands out a Bath newspaper: married at St Ambrose's on the seventeenth. He tells Boldwood his is the ridiculous fate of those who come between a man and his wife. He says he is not villain enough to make any woman's marriage or misery a matter of huckster and sale, and that Fanny left him long ago, and he does not know where she is. Boldwood believed in Bathsheba's dishonour on slight evidence, he adds, and a fig for such love. He wraps the gold in the notes and throws it into the road. Boldwood shakes his fist and swears to punish him. The door locks. All that night his dark form walks the hills and downs like an unhappy Shade in the Mournful Fields by Acheron.
Hardy understood something that still confuses people today: emotional problems require emotional solutions, not financial ones. Boldwood's attempt to pay Troy to leave town represents a pattern we see everywhere—the belief that if we just find the right incentive, we can control other people's feelings. But love, respect, and loyalty can't be purchased because they're based on genuine connection, shared values, and mutual choice. When we try to buy these things, we actually push them further away. The person offering money reveals their desperation, making themselves less attractive. The person being offered money either takes advantage (like Troy) or feels insulted by the implication that their feelings are for sale. This creates a lose-lose situation where the desperate person becomes prey and the relationship becomes transactional rather than authentic. Modern examples are everywhere: parents buying expensive gifts instead of spending time with their kids, managers offering bonuses to avoid addressing workplace toxicity, friends who always pay the bill hoping to buy affection. The pattern fails because it treats symptoms rather than causes. Real relationship problems require honest conversation, behavior change, and emotional work—none of which can be outsourced or purchased. When we recognize this pattern in ourselves, we can step back and ask what we're really trying to buy, then address the underlying issue directly.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion