Before Troy is seen again, Hardy stops to take his measure, and the portrait is not flattering. Troy has no use for memory or hope. For him the past is yesterday and the future is to-morrow, never the day after, so he is never disappointed, and he does not miss what he has never had, which makes him seem to enjoy more than sober people do. He is fairly truthful to men, but to women he lies like a Cretan, which wins him a quick welcome in lively company, since the favour so gained is only a matter for the future to settle. His vices come by impulse and his virtues by cool thought, and the second are talked about more often than seen. He speaks fluently and without stopping, so that he can speak of love and think of dinner, or be eager to pay and mean to owe.
Hardy then turns to flattery, which every man knows works on women and almost none has tested. Troy has tested it. He has been heard to say that with womankind there are only two methods, flattery or cursing and swearing, and that if you treat them fairly you are a lost man.
A week or two after the shearing, Bathsheba, glad of Boldwood's absence, walks out to her hayfields. Among the gnarled forms of the men and the flexible forms of the women in their tilt bonnets, a bright scarlet spot comes out from behind a waggon and goes on loading hay as if it belonged there. It is the sergeant, who has come haymaking for pleasure, and nobody can deny that he does the mistress real knight-service by it. He sees her, sticks his pitchfork in the ground, picks up his cane and comes forward. Bathsheba blushes with half-angry embarrassment, and fixes her eyes and her feet on the straight line of her path.
Hardy shows us something unsettling about human psychology: some people genuinely cannot learn from past mistakes because they refuse to connect their actions to consequences. This isn't stupidity—it's a defense mechanism that keeps them functional but makes them dangerous to others. Troy represents what psychologists now call 'temporal myopia'—the inability to see beyond the immediate moment. This creates a person who can lie effortlessly because they're not thinking about being caught later, who can make promises they can't keep because future Troy will deal with future problems. In working-class communities, we encounter these people regularly: the coworker who borrows money every payday but never pays back, the romantic partner who creates the same fight every few months but acts shocked when you're upset, the family member who promises to help with elderly care but disappears when it's time to act. They're not evil—they're operating from a fundamentally different relationship with time and consequence. The key insight Hardy offers is that you can't change these people by appealing to their conscience or pointing out patterns, because pattern-recognition requires connecting past to present to future, which is exactly what they cannot do. Your only protection is to judge them by their history, not their current performance, and set boundaries based on what they've done before, not what they promise to do next.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion