On 10 June Smith calls with a ticket for the next Hampstead assembly and will not take a refusal. He presses until Evelina is wearied to death, then calls her coy when she stays resolute. She will not give reasons he cannot remove. He turns to Madame Duval, who scolds him for not asking her first, then accepts a ticket of her own and promises to take Evelina whenever he pleases. He leaves in triumph. Duval laughs at the scruple of a present from a stranger, calls Evelina a foolish country girl, and says she will teach her something of the world. The ball is next week. Evelina means to avoid it, and hopes Miss Branghton may help, since she too dislikes the thought of Evelina dancing with Smith.
On the 11th Duval sends her to the Branghtons with an invitation, and Du Bois attends her. In the shop the lodger slips on the stairs and a pistol shows. She follows softly, sees him kneel with two pistols, and hears him ask God to forgive him. Strength comes at once. She rushes in, catches his arm, and falls senseless beside him. The pistols are on the floor when she rises. He seizes them again. She holds both his arms and cries out for mercy on himself. He calls her Heaven's angel, then stops her once more. She says she will awaken him to worthier thoughts and rescue him from perdition, takes the pistols, and totters downstairs.
He follows, asking if he dreams. She keeps the weapons when his eyes return to them, and begs him to forbear so there is time to think. The Branghtons' voices below send him to his knee at her gown, then flying to his room. She faints before they reach her. They find the pistols by her side and think her dead. She urges them to watch the lodger and to keep every means of self-destruction from him, then goes home in a chair. She writes that his misery fills her thoughts. If he is bent on destroying himself, every effort to save him may still fail.
The Branghtons reveal something ugly but universal: how insecure people often build themselves up by tearing others down. They need the Scottish poet to be worthless because it makes them feel valuable by comparison. This isn't just historical snobbery—it's a survival mechanism that backfires spectacularly. In Burney's time, rigid class systems made this behaviour somewhat predictable. Today's supposed meritocracy makes it more insidious. We tell ourselves we judge people fairly based on their choices and achievements, but we're often just using different markers for the same shallow assessment. The person at the food bank might be a laid-off engineer. The quiet coworker might be supporting sick parents. The neighbour with the beat-up car might be saving every penny for their kid's education. When we dismiss people based on surface evidence, we don't just miss their stories—we miss opportunities for connection, learning, and growth. We also reveal our own character flaws. The Branghtons think they're demonstrating superiority, but they're actually showing their fear, ignorance, and emotional poverty. Evelina's different response—seeing the poet's humanity despite his circumstances—demonstrates true refinement. Real strength doesn't need to diminish others to shine.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion