In the 15th century most English people were free peasant owners. Serfdom had practically gone by the end of the 14th, and even the farm labourers had cottages, four or more acres, and the common land for their cattle, wood and turf. A lord's power then rested on how many subjects he had, which meant on how many peasants held land. That world allowed what Chancellor Fortescue praised as the wealth of the people, but it shut out capitalist wealth. The break came in the last third of the 15th century. Bands of feudal retainers were dissolved and thrown on the labour market, and the great lords made a far larger proletariat by driving peasants off the land and seizing the commons. The rise of Flemish wool manufacture raised the price of wool in England and gave the push. The new nobility, for which money was the power of all powers, had a cry: turn arable land into sheep-walks. Harrison saw seventeen, eighteen or twenty houses shrunk in a single manor. Henry VII in 1489 forbade pulling down any farmhouse with twenty acres, and a law of 1533 limited flocks to 2,000 sheep where some owners had 24,000. For 150 years the complaints and the laws were alike fruitless.
Marx says the laws failed because capitalism needed the opposite of what they protected: a degraded, almost servile mass of people. The same fight went on over the labourer's four acres. Roger Crocker was condemned in 1627 for building a cottage without them, and a royal commission in 1638 tried to enforce the old laws. In the end, Dr. Hunter reports, landlords and farmers worked hand in hand against the rule, because a few acres to the cottage would make labourers too independent. The Reformation then gave the expropriation a new and frightful push. Church lands, which covered a great part of England, were given to royal favourites or sold cheaply to speculating farmers who drove out the hereditary sub-tenants. The monasteries' inmates were thrown into the proletariat, and Queen Elizabeth cried that the poor lay everywhere. In the 43rd year of her reign the nation had to admit pauperism with a poor-rate. After the Restoration the landlords got rid of their duties to the State, covered the loss with taxes on the common people, and claimed the land as modern private property. The glorious Revolution then brought in William of Orange and a new set of landlords who gave away, sold or simply annexed Crown estates, the base of the oligarchy's princely domains. By about 1750 the yeomanry had gone.
In the 18th century the law itself became the tool. Acts for the enclosure of commons were decrees by which landlords granted themselves the people's land. Marx quotes the complaints. In Hertfordshire 24 farms were melted into three. In Northamptonshire and Leicestershire, where 1,500 acres were once ploughed, some lordships did not plough 50. A hundred houses in an open-field village dwindled to eight or ten. Four or five graziers could swallow a lordship that had supported twenty or thirty farmers. Dr. Price saw that little farmers would become labourers who must buy everything at market, so that there would be more labour because there would be more compulsion. A defender of enclosure agreed that this was an advantage. Between 1765 and 1780, Eden admits, agricultural wages fell below the minimum and were topped up from the poor-rate. Eden's own comfort was that the right proportion of pasture to arable had at last been reached. Marx asks whether the people got a farthing for the 3,511,770 acres of common land that were taken between 1801 and 1831.
The last act is the clearing of estates, and the Highlands show it. The Gaelic clans held their land in common, with the chief only the titular owner. Once the chiefs had no wars to fight, they turned their nominal right into private property and set about driving their clansmen out. The Duchess of Sutherland set out to turn the whole country into a sheep-walk. From 1814 to 1820 some 15,000 people, about 3,000 families, were hunted and rooted out. Their villages were burned, British soldiers enforced it, and one old woman burned to death in her hut rather than leave. The Duchess took 794,000 acres, gave the evicted 6,000 acres on the sea-shore at two acres a family, and charged them rent. She laid the clan land out as 29 great sheep farms, each held by one family of mostly English farm servants. By 1835, 131,000 sheep had replaced the 15,000 Gaels. The few left on the shore tried to live by fishing, until the landlords let the shore to London fishmongers and they were hunted out a second time. Then sheep-walks became deer forests. Somers wrote in 1848 that forests were springing up like mushrooms and that deer-forests and the people cannot co-exist, since a range laid out as forest often paid better than a range let to sheep. Marx lists the church lands, the state domains, the commons and the clan lands, and calls them idyllic methods of primitive accumulation. They won the field for capitalist farming, made the soil part of capital, and supplied the towns with a free and outlawed proletariat.
The footnotes show that nothing about it was hidden. Thomas More had written that the sheep now devoured the very men. Southern parish landowners laid out a plan to build a prison, invite bids for taking the poor off the parish's hands, and refuse relief to anyone who would not be locked up. In 1698 Fletcher of Saltoun counted 200,000 beggars in Scotland and proposed making them slaves. Marx notes that in 1860 people expropriated by force were shipped to Canada under false pretences. When a later Duchess of Sutherland feasted Mrs. Beecher Stowe in London to show her sympathy for American slaves, he published the facts about the Sutherland slaves in the New York Tribune. In North Germany, Mirabeau found the peasant ploughing all summer and, in winter, spinning flax late into the night just to pay his taxes. The 1866 notes bring the Highlands up to date. Professor Leone Levi described land that grew excellent grass become deer ground. The Economist reported that one of the finest sheep farms in Sutherlandshire, offered £1,200 a year in rent, was to become a deer-forest. The paper wrote that such made-up deserts ought to be put down by the decided interference of the Legislature. Marx has already shown what that Legislature did with the commons.
Marx forces us to confront an uncomfortable truth: extreme wealth doesn't come from working harder or being smarter. It comes from taking what others built. The English landlords didn't create the land or make it fertile—generations of peasants did that work. But the landlords had the power to steal it legally and call it progress. This pattern hasn't changed. Today's billionaires didn't build the internet infrastructure their companies depend on—taxpayers did. They didn't educate their workers—public schools did. They didn't create the legal system that protects their property—society did. Yet they capture the value while claiming they earned it all themselves. The most successful businesses today extract wealth that communities and workers created, then use that wealth to extract even more. Amazon didn't create the postal system, roads, or educated workforce that make their business possible, but they profit from all of it while paying minimal taxes back to the communities that enabled their success. When we understand that extreme inequality isn't natural but manufactured through systematic extraction, we can start asking better questions: Who really created the value? Who's capturing it? And what would happen if we changed the rules to match the reality of how wealth gets created?
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion