The first sign that a person is walking this night of sense is a double dryness: no pleasure in the things of God, and no pleasure in created things either. God has set the soul here to quench sensual desire, so he will not let sweetness attach anywhere. That is how you tell the dryness from fresh sin. If a new indulgence were the cause, desire would still lean towards something else. Here nothing pulls. The old consolations are gone and the substitutes do not work.
The second sign is anxious care for God. The soul thinks it is not serving him, that it is backsliding, because sweetness has vanished. That worry is a good sign. If the dryness came from sin or slackness, the soul would grow indifferent and stop caring. This anxiety still wants God without the old feeling, which is why the dryness is purgation rather than collapse.
The third and surest sign is that meditation will not run. However hard the soul tries, it cannot reflect with the imagination as it used to. God now communicates by pure spirit, by an act of simple contemplation, not through sense, forms, and images. The blocked imagination is not a failed technique. It is a change of channel. Saint John says the three signs together mark this night, not a season you should fix by hunting a new high.
Saint Juan wrote during the Spanish Inquisition, when showing spiritual doubt could literally get you killed. Yet he insisted that feeling spiritually empty or confused often indicated progress, not heresy. This was revolutionary thinking - suggesting that divine connection might require losing familiar forms of comfort and certainty. Today we face a different but related pressure: our culture demands constant emotional satisfaction and measurable progress. Social media feeds us endless content designed to provide quick hits of pleasure and validation. Self-help culture promises that growth should feel good, that the right techniques will eliminate discomfort. But real development - whether in relationships, careers, or personal growth - often requires a period of not knowing, of losing old sources of satisfaction before new ones emerge. The nurse who's ready for more responsibility feels restless in her current role. The parent whose relationship with their teenager is shifting feels like they're failing when old approaches stop working. The person in recovery finds that meetings that once provided comfort now feel insufficient. Our instinct is to panic, to force old solutions, or to assume we're regressing. But recognizing these three signs - loss of old satisfactions, anxiety about performance, and ineffective familiar strategies - can help us understand we're not broken but evolving. The discomfort isn't a bug in the system; it's a feature of authentic growth.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion