LIVE
OCD← Home
As I Lay Dying cover
1930
As I Lay Dying
William Faulkner · Fish, Horse, and Is-Was
Chapter 24
Ch. 23
Reading
Ch. 24
Ch. 25
Loading audio...
0:000:00

We are going to town, Vardaman says. Dewey Dell tells him the train in the window won't be sold because it belongs to Santa Claus until next Christmas, when it will shine behind the glass again. Pa and Cash come down the hill, but Jewel is going to the barn. You leave that horse here, Pa says. We'll all go in the wagon with ma, like she wanted. Jewel's eyes look like marbles. He does not stop.

But my mother is a fish, Vardaman thinks. Vernon seen it. He was there. Darl says Jewel's mother is a horse. Then what is your ma, Darl? If I had one, it is was, Darl says, and if it is was, it can't be is. Then I am not, Darl says. But you are, Darl, Vardaman answers. That's why I am not is, Darl says. Are is too many for one woman to foal.

Cash will stop at Tull's on the way back and get on that barn roof. It ain't respectful, Pa says. It's a deliberate flouting of her and of me. Dewey Dell climbs into the wagon with Mrs. Tull's cakes. It's a flouting of the dead, Pa says again. It'll be there come Christmas, Dewey Dell says, shining on the track. Who hears the child's equation when the loudest mourner is counting slights?

Amplified Discussion
The Grammar Chapter

Chapter 24 is Vardaman's fourth turn and the novel's clearest stack of impossible family math. Fish from the boy. Horse from Darl's memory of Jewel. Is was from Darl's own mouth. Foaling from livestock logic. Anse shaving because my mother is a fish lands as child logic meeting adult performance in one line.

Around the riddles the trip actually starts. Jewel walks to the barn. Cash will roof at Tull's. Dewey Dell carries cakes and Santa Claus hope. Anse repeats flouting as if the word could freeze everyone in place.

Faulkner lets the youngest narrator host the wordplay because Vardaman treats each line as serious reporting. Darl is my brother. I am. The chapter ends with Christmas shining on the track while Addie rides toward Jefferson in the wagon none of them can describe in ordinary language.

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Listen Under the Flouting

Has a family fight about respect ever drowned out a child's or teen's odd true line underneath? Vardaman holds to my mother is a fish while Darl turns mother into is-was grammar and Anse calls cakes and barn roofs flouting of the dead. This week, when adults argue about what's disrespectful on a travel day, listen for the impossible sentence someone younger is holding steady before you side with the loudest mourner.

Lessons

PracticeWhen a respect fight breaks out on travel day, listen for the odd true line beneath the shouting.

Psych reading

Equations Instead of Mothers

When direct grief language fails, family members may replace the mother with animals, grammar, or rules about respect while the burial trip moves forward anyway.

In the mind

Some families answer death with equations instead of comfort. Vardaman says fish. Darl says horse. Then Darl says is was and cannot be is until Vardaman cannot tell whether his brother exists.

The pattern works like this. The youngest holds one impossible fact. The seer turns it into riddles. The father calls every practical move flouting. The trip starts anyway.

You have seen this when kids ask plain questions at the worst moment and adults answer with logic, jokes, or rules about respect instead of touch.

The skill is to hear what each sentence protects. Vardaman protects belief. Darl protects distance. Anse protects his image. Jewel protects the horse. None of them is naming Addie straight, and the wagon is already going to town.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors