Stiva will tell himself the truth, but only the kind that keeps him comfortable. He does not repent the affair with their former governess; he repents failing to hide it better. He had vaguely assumed Darya Alexandrovna would long ago have suspected him, shut her eyes, and take an indulgent view like other wives he knows. It turned out quite the other way, and now he circles the same cry without a plan: awful, awful, what is to be done?
When thought offers no exit, he reaches for the answer life gives to every hard question: live in the needs of the day, forget oneself. Sleep and last night's dream are closed to him, so he rises, rings for Matvey, reads telegrams, and brightens when his sister Anna Arkadyevna arrives tomorrow, alone. Matvey reads the visit as hope for reconciliation. Stiva sends the telegram to Dolly and waits. Her answer comes back through Matvey: she is going away, and he may do as he likes. Matrona, Dolly's chief ally in the house, still begs him to go, own his fault again, pray, pity the children. He says Dolly will not see him, blushes, sends her off, and tells Matvey to dress him.
Anna arrives tomorrow, alone, and Stiva will greet her hope before he has offered Dolly anything Matrona would call an apology.
Stepan Oblonsky has just destroyed his wife's world, yet Tolstoy presents him as almost sympathetic: confused, bumbling, genuinely fond of his family. This narrative choice reveals something uncomfortable about human nature. We often empathize with the person who caused harm rather than the person experiencing it. Why? Because we can more easily imagine being the one who made a mistake than the one betrayed. Stepan's perspective is familiar. Who has not acted selfishly and then felt bad about feeling bad? His comfortable life, his charm, and his genuine bewilderment at the consequences make him relatable. Meanwhile, Dolly's rage and pain remain largely offscreen in this chapter. Tolstoy understood that readers would naturally align with the character whose inner world we inhabit, even when that character is morally wrong. This same dynamic plays out constantly in modern life. We sympathize with the friend who had to cancel plans rather than the one left hanging. We understand the coworker who did not mean to take credit rather than the one whose work was stolen. We relate to the family member who just cannot help their destructive patterns rather than those cleaning up the damage. Recognizing this bias in ourselves, our tendency to empathize with familiar selfishness over unfamiliar suffering, is crucial for moral growth. When we catch ourselves feeling sorry for someone who caused harm simply because we understand their perspective, we can choose to redirect our empathy toward those who actually need it.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion