Karenin enters Lydia Ivanovna's snug boudoir with china, portraits, and a New Testament on the table. She flushes crimson and gives him Anna's letter. After reading it he sits silent, then says timidly that he does not think he has the right to refuse her. Lydia insists there are limits: she can understand immorality but not cruelty to him. Who is to throw a stone, Karenin answers, pleased with his part; he cannot deprive her love for her son.
Lydia counters that Seryozha looks on his mother as dead and prays for her sins; seeing her would harm the angel. Karenin had not thought of that and agrees. After prayer she advises refusal and offers to write. He consents. Her French letter tells Anna that reminding the child of her would implant censure toward what should be sacred and asks her to interpret refusal in the spirit of Christian love. It wounds Anna to the quick.
Returning home Karenin cannot concentrate or find spiritual peace. Memories torture him: receiving her confession at the races, not challenging Vronsky, forgiveness nobody wanted, caring for another man's child. He thinks of Vronsky and gentlemen with fine calves, then tries to live for eternity. Trivial mistakes still torment him as if salvation did not exist. Soon peace and elevation return, and he can forget what he does not want to remember.
Part V, Chapter 25 is Karenin's moral test and failure in one sitting. The boudoir props, New Testament, and portraits frame a scene that looks like counsel but functions as capture. Karenin's timid right to refuse is the chapter's hinge. Lydia's limits to everything and cruelty speech invert morality: Anna becomes aggressor. Who is to throw a stone lets Karenin feel saintly while Lydia writes the blade. The French letter's spirit of censure is Tolstoy at his most forensic about Petersburg piety. Karenin's afternoon shame, fine calves, and races memory show what elevation suppresses. The closing peace is not healing; it is managed amnesia. Anna's plot and Seryozha's plot converge on this withheld meeting.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion