From talks with Betsy and Stiva, Karenin understands he must leave Anna in peace without burdening her, and that she wants this. He cannot decide anything himself and assents to those glad to manage his affairs. Only when Anna has left and the English governess asks whether to dine with him does he grasp his position and feel appalled. He cannot connect tender care for his sick wife and her child with being now alone, shamed, laughed at, needed by no one.
For two days he preserves composure at committee and dinner, answering about Anna's rooms as if events were ordinary. On the second day a draper's bill Anna forgot breaks him. He sends the clerk away, sinks his head in his hands, cancels the carriage, and skips dinner. He feels universal contempt, hatred not because he is bad but because he is repulsively unhappy. In all Petersburg he has no one to receive his sorrow as a man, only as an official.
His orphan childhood and uncle's upbringing produced medals and ambition but no close friend. Women, especially Countess Lydia Ivanovna, are terrible and distasteful to him. Work will become refuge; breakdown comes alone. The chapter turns the Anna plot toward Karenin's despair before Lydia's visit.
Part V, Chapter 21 shifts the novel's center to Petersburg and to a man Tolstoy refuses to caricature. Karenin's assent to leave Anna in peace is not nobility but paralysis. The governess's dinner question makes abstraction impossible: he is a solitary father in a house designed for a marriage. Two days of composure show his lifelong skill; the draper's bill shows its limit. The autobiographical digression on orphanhood and career explains why Sludin and the doctor cannot receive his sorrow. Women are distasteful to him, yet Lydia Ivanovna will soon enter, which makes the closing sentence ominous. Karenin is not only wronged husband but man crushed by a society that hates torn dogs that yelp.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion