The empty-chair trick lasts ten or fifteen minutes and cannot safely be repeated, so Alice counts the young men lounging in the doorways and hates every one of them. Ella Dowling sits through dance after dance like a painted wooden figure, but Ella has her mother beside her and the excuse of being a spectator. For a girl who has been a belle it is worse. Why had she thought this time might be different? Why had she broken her back for those violets? When a man finally crosses to her, it is Harvey Malone, glossy and easy, who calls her 'Lady Alicia', drops into her absent partner's chair, and promises, as he has before, that he really is going to call on her some evening.
Alice retreats to the dressing-room and fusses with a slipper buckle until the attendant kindly sews it fast, which leaves her nothing to do but go. She asks the man at the cloak-room door to find her brother. Once she has gone he bursts out laughing, because Walter is behind the coats on his knees, shooting dice with the attendants. Alice takes refuge among the mothers and talks brightly to Mrs. George Dresser, who answers with dry nods. Frank Dowling dances with her again, and another girl's diamond pin tears the back of her dress.
Then Mildred brings Arthur Russell to her. Alice takes it as charity: a young hostess makes her fiancé dance with the unpopular girls. He is friendly and says 'That's splendid!' after the music, and she supposes he said the same to Ella. She sends him back to Mildred, but first asks him to find Walter. Mrs. Dresser moves away to sit with Mrs. Palmer, and Alice is left against the wall between empty chairs. Russell does bring Walter, who is furious: that man asked everyone in the house whether he was Mr. Walter Adams, and found him at the dice. At home her mother asks if she had a good time. 'Just lovely!' Alice says, and hums a dance tune on the stairs. At her bedroom door she throws herself into her mother's arms, sobbing so loudly that her father wakes.
Alice's breakdown reveals something brutal about how we handle social rejection. When our sense of worth comes from external validation, losing that validation doesn't make us step back and reassess, it makes us perform harder. Alice cycles through increasingly pathetic strategies because she can't accept that her social status has changed. Her entire identity was built on being the belle of the ball, so she doubles down, performing cheerfulness while dying inside. This exact pattern plays out everywhere today. The coworker who stays late every night after being passed over for promotion, desperately trying to prove their worth. The parent oversharing their child's achievements on social media while their marriage crumbles. The person drowning in debt but still picking up restaurant tabs to maintain their generous image. The employee who laughs at every joke and volunteers for everything, terrified their job isn't secure. The gap between public performance and private reality grows wider with each rejection, creating an exhausting cycle. Tarkington shows us that the real tragedy isn't the initial rejection, it's how we trap ourselves in increasingly desperate performances instead of honestly facing what's changed. When you can spot this pattern in yourself, you can choose authentic response over frantic image management.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion