On the Beauforts' lawn at Newport, girls in starched muslin step out of a tent and loose arrows at two targets, and the August archery meeting goes on exactly as it always has. Newland Archer watches from the verandah, surprised that nothing has changed except him. Through the winter in New York, the office, his new library and evenings out kept married life feeling real. Newport, the holiday he tried to swap for a remote island off Maine, strips that away. He tells himself May has given him all he expected, and that Ellen Olenska is now only 'the most plaintive and poignant of a line of ghosts'. Yet his mind feels empty and echoing, and the cheerful crowd strikes him like children playing in a graveyard.
Then the Marchioness Manson flutters out and says 'my Ellen', and Archer's heart gives a jerk that slams a door on the world. Medora chatters about the Blenkers, Dr Carver's Inner Thought meetings and Ellen's refusal to stay at Newport. Beaufort joins them, heavy and bloated, trailed by rumours of a West Indies cruise and a lady resembling Fanny Ring. May steps up in white with ivy on her hat, and her final bull's-eye wins the prize. When Lawrence Lefferts praises the way she holds the bow, Beaufort answers that it is the only kind of target she will ever hit. Archer is angry, then uneasy: what if May's famous niceness is a curtain dropped in front of nothing?
May drives him out to Granny Mingott's cottage to show off her diamond-tipped arrow. The old lady teases her about leaving it to her eldest girl until May blushes crimson, then mentions that Ellen is spending the day with her and has gone down to the shore. 'Run down and fetch her,' she tells Archer. Below the willows he sees a woman at the end of a little pier, her back to the land. He makes a bargain: if she does not turn before a sailing boat passes the Lime Rock light, he will go back. The boat passes. She does not move. He walks up the hill.
On the drive home May says she is sorry he missed Ellen, then adds, with a hardness he has never heard in her voice, that Ellen might be happier with her husband. Archer laughs and calls it the first cruel thing he has heard her say, and May's placid reply files him among the unreasonable husbands. The Welland house, which used to soothe him with its clocks and calling cards, now feels unreal, while the moment on the bank feels as close as his own blood. All night he lies awake beside May, watching the moonlight slant across the carpet and thinking of Ellen driving home behind Beaufort's trotters.
Wharton wrote during America's Gilded Age, when rapid industrialization created new wealth and rigid social expectations about how to display it properly. The Newport summer season was theater, elaborate performances of status that consumed enormous energy while producing little genuine satisfaction. Today's version looks different but follows identical patterns. We chase promotions in jobs that drain us, stay in relationships that look good on paper, buy houses in neighborhoods that impress others while bankrupting our peace of mind. The mechanism remains the same: we trade pieces of our authentic selves for external validation, then wonder why success feels hollow. Archer's marriage to May represents this perfectly, she's everything society says he should want, yet her very perfection highlights what's missing. Modern parallels abound: the nurse who stays at a prestigious hospital despite toxic management because it looks good on her resume, the mechanic who takes a supervisor role he hates because his family expects him to 'move up,' the parent who pushes their artistic child toward business school because it seems more secure. The tragedy isn't wanting stability or recognition, it's losing track of whose definition of success we're actually pursuing. When we can name this pattern, we gain power to choose differently. The question becomes: are we building our own dreams or performing someone else's script?
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion