May has been let off church because her mother has just won her over to a long engagement, so Archer has her to himself for a walk in the Park under a lapis lazuli sky, the snow shining like splintered crystals. She thanks him for the lilies that come because he remembers each day, not by standing order. Feeling rich and secure, he mentions the yellow roses he sent Madame Olenska. May is delighted, but Ellen lunched with them that day and spoke of Beaufort's orchids and cousin Henry's carnations, not of any roses. Archer remembers he left no card, and he does not mention that he called on her.
He presses May to shorten the engagement, to travel, to strike out for themselves. She gives the answers her upbringing supplied: why aren't they very well off as they are? When she calls him original, he answers that they are all like paper dolls cut from the same fold. He thinks of the Kentucky cave-fish that stopped growing eyes because they had no use for them, and wonders whether May, once he takes off the bandage, will only look out "blankly at blankness". When he keeps asking why not, she calls eloping "rather vulgar", relieved to have found the word, and closes the subject by telling him Ellen admired her ring.
The next afternoon Janey brings news: Madame Olenska went to Mrs Lemuel Struthers's Sunday party with the Duke and Beaufort, and the van der Luydens are so upset they are going back to Skuytercliff. Archer says he does not care a brass farthing about Family and that the real culprit is the Duke under their own roof. His mother wants him to explain things to cousin Louisa. While they argue, Henry van der Luyden arrives in person, pleased with himself. He has called on Ellen, admired the way she scattered his carnations, and given her a friendly warning, which she received gratefully. Archer's angry afternoon changed nothing, and Henry's single quiet visit settled everything, so whose voice does New York actually hear?
Wharton shows us something devastating: May has been so perfectly trained to be the 'right' kind of woman that she's lost access to her own desires. When Archer suggests travel or breaking convention, she automatically responds with what she's been taught to say, not what she might actually want. This creates a tragic irony, the better she performs her role, the more isolated she becomes. Today, this pattern shows up everywhere. In healthcare, patients give doctors 'good patient' answers instead of describing their real symptoms. At work, employees offer safe responses in meetings instead of honest feedback, leading to poor decisions. On social media, we curate perfect lives that get likes but leave us feeling empty. The mechanism is always the same: we learn that certain responses keep us safe and approved of, so we default to them automatically. But safety comes at a cost, we lose the ability to form genuine connections. Real relationships require vulnerability, disagreement, and the messy process of figuring out what we actually think. When we're always performing the 'right' response, we become strangers to ourselves and impossible to truly know. The question isn't whether we should abandon all social norms, but whether we can learn to distinguish between helpful guidelines and scripts that prevent authentic living.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion